Hidden gems: American restaurants in Pleasant Prairie

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Pleasant Prairie. This list contains 18 places from American restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Hot Dish Pantry image
1
Hot Dish Pantry
American restaurant
$ $$$
4.90 (127 reviews) (~49.4 km from centre)
Big Belly Deli image
2
Big Belly Deli
Deli
👍👍 WOW! The food from Big Belly Deli is incredible! Super delicious! We started with the fried pickles…. Then I had the gyro sandwich and my wife had the Philly Cheesesteak. Everything was delicious! I highly recommend Big Belly Deli. Try it…. You won’t regret it!
$$ $$
4.90 (56 reviews) (~19.24 km from centre)
Cansino's Pizzeria & Restaurant image
3
Cansino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Great pizza, very tasty, fresh toppings. Most places around HP have jalapenos that are not fresh, their's are very tasty. Fries are also really good as is the Italian beef.
4.90 (54 reviews) (~34.49 km from centre)
Supremefries and More image
4
Supremefries and More
Hamburger restaurant
👍👍 Was dying to try this place, and they didn’t disappoint!! They took the time to craft their food, and (I believe) one of the owners handed us our food and was so nice and asked if it was our first time here. She asked my boyfriend if he wanted the hot or mild jerk chicken, and he opted for the hot....
$$ $$
4.80 (111 reviews) (~7.85 km from centre)
Mother Cluckers Chicken image
5
Mother Cluckers Chicken
Chicken restaurant
👍👍 A hidden gem! The crispy and flavorful fried chicken stole the show, but what truly impressed me were the garlic mashed potatoes and honey butter biscuits. I have never had chicken and sides this good from chicken spot. Also, the friendly staff made the dining experience even more delightful.
$ $$$
4.80 (52 reviews) (~15.77 km from centre)
Little Honeycomb image
6
Little Honeycomb
Restaurant
👍👍 Odd little restaurant. The menu covers a variety of cuisines with a slight focus in mexican. The food was tasty(nachos, burger, fries). The staff were a little stretched but it was packed and labor day. Would go back. Only annoyance is the very bass-driven music inside.
$$ $$
4.70 (125 reviews) (~47.86 km from centre)
Eli's Cafe and Pancake House image
7
Eli's Cafe and Pancake House
American restaurant
👍👍 Looking for a quick delicious breakfast or lunch stop by Eli's stumbled across this little place and it has become a happy accident fast delicious food, staff is always friendly and inviting. A great little place to be
4.70 (59 reviews) (~10.73 km from centre)
White Hart Pub image
8
White Hart Pub
Pub
👍👍 What a great pub experience! Never been there before but for sure will be back... great beers and cocktails even chartuse? Sp? Which we have not seen at bars in years.
4.70 (11 reviews) (~30.89 km from centre)
Frank & Betsie's Restaurant image
9
Frank & Betsie's Restaurant
French restaurant
European & American dishes plated in a casual, sophisticated space with outdoor seating.
4.60 (139 reviews) (~46.19 km from centre)
Big O's Texas BBQ image
10
Big O's Texas BBQ
Barbecue restaurant
4.60 (107 reviews) (~38.5 km from centre)
Noble Brothers Burger Shop image
11
Noble Brothers Burger Shop
American restaurant
👍👍 You have the BEST Burgers, Fries and Chili anywhere! I You have figured out how to deliver the.tastiest fast food around…your ice dream and cheese are top shelf as well! Thank you for nourishing both my body and soul. I always look forward to my next visit to your establishment. Love those skin on...
$ $$$
4.60 (84 reviews) (~39.61 km from centre)
Lake Forest Food & Wine image
12
Lake Forest Food & Wine
American restaurant
$$ $$
4.60 (69 reviews) (~30.65 km from centre)
Lucky Lulu's image
13
Lucky Lulu's
American restaurant
👍👍 Love the vibe here! Fireplace, cozy seating, great drinks and shareable foods like sliders & flatbread pizzas. Friendly service and fun games like shuffleboard, darts and slots. They have a cool golf simulator room in the back. Great for groups.
$$ $$
4.50 (135 reviews) (~43.3 km from centre)
Kraby J's image
14
Kraby J's
Restaurant
👍👍 New ownership/management took over 12/1/23. Food is amazing!! My husband and I tried a couple different options. Pizza is classic Chicago tavern and it was cooked PERFECTLY. Nice crispy cracker caramelized cheese crust! Cobb salad was delicious. It had thick pieces of bacon that literally melted in...
4.50 (100 reviews) (~25.38 km from centre)
Vero International Cuisine image
15
Vero International Cuisine
Small plates restaurant
Global-style cuisine, including many Caribbean dishes, plus cocktails, served in a modern space.
4.50 (89 reviews) (~22.95 km from centre)
The Blue Heron Cafe & Lounge image
16
The Blue Heron Cafe & Lounge
Bar
😠 Walked in after watching Gattaca, very hungry and wanting a delicious bloody mary. Little did I know I was gonna get a mouthful of rust! Food was low quality, I ordered a pizza and it had canned cheese. When I went home I puked for hours. Thanks for the experiece, Blue Heron. I wont be back!
$ $$$
4.50 (66 reviews) (~47.14 km from centre)
Cellar 26 image
17
Cellar 26
American restaurant
👍👍 What a hidden (literally) gem! The food and drinks were amazing. The ambience is great. There’s music but it’s quiet enough to actually be able to have a conversation.
4.50 (18 reviews) (~27.67 km from centre)
The Bistro - Eat. Drink. Connect.® image
18
The Bistro - Eat. Drink. Connect.®
American restaurant
4.50 (12 reviews) (~20.4 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Pleasant Prairie

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )