Hidden gems: Sandwich shops in Pleasant Prairie

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Pleasant Prairie. This list contains 16 places from Sandwich shop category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


DeLishka Sandwiches & Bites image
1
DeLishka Sandwiches & Bites
Sandwich shop
👍👍 Wow is it good! At the location Red Rooster used to be(which i liked and was sad when it left) is now DeLishka, which is another deli style sandwich joint but this one is all European meats & cheeses on skinny baguettes and wow is it good. the Pierogis were excellent and the sandwiches are unique an...
$$ $$
5.00 (84 reviews) (~49.07 km from centre)
Ella Bonella image
2
Ella Bonella
Bakery
👍👍 Perfect pie! We had a picnic with this strawberry pie and it was delicious and kept well in the box while we were heading there. The baker was very nice and gave me some utensils and napkins! You need to order the day before but it’s worth it.
5.00 (42 reviews) (~46.79 km from centre)
Scungilli’s Sandwich Shop image
3
Scungilli’s Sandwich Shop
Sandwich shop
4.90 (89 reviews) (~38.62 km from centre)
Lakeside Subs image
4
Lakeside Subs
Sandwich shop
👍👍 Great food at a great price, not to mention locally-owned. Deb is not only warm and friendly, but also a very hands-on owner and is typically doing all the work herself! Her subs, cookies, and soups are all wonderful. I like that you can get any sub done as a wrap, and most (if not all) of their dre...
$ $$$
4.90 (65 reviews) (~47.94 km from centre)
Cansino's Pizzeria & Restaurant image
5
Cansino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Great pizza, very tasty, fresh toppings. Most places around HP have jalapenos that are not fresh, their's are very tasty. Fries are also really good as is the Italian beef.
4.90 (54 reviews) (~34.49 km from centre)
Cribb Fine Foods Inc image
6
Cribb Fine Foods Inc
Butcher shop deli
👍👍 My first visit was a couple of weeks ago on the recommendation of a friend and I was blown away by how good the t-bone steaks were when I cooked them on the grill that night. Outstanding marbling and the taste was out of this world. Since returned and bought pork chops and they were also excellen...
4.80 (82 reviews) (~17.66 km from centre)
Captain John's Sammys & Such image
7
Captain John's Sammys & Such
Sandwich shop
👍👍 I have going to this location since 1990’s. John does an amazing job! Best dang sandwich in the area! I drive from Milwaukee just to have 1 of his sandwiches. Delicious!
$ $$$
4.80 (80 reviews) (~24 km from centre)
Little Honeycomb image
8
Little Honeycomb
Restaurant
👍👍 Odd little restaurant. The menu covers a variety of cuisines with a slight focus in mexican. The food was tasty(nachos, burger, fries). The staff were a little stretched but it was packed and labor day. Would go back. Only annoyance is the very bass-driven music inside.
$$ $$
4.70 (125 reviews) (~47.86 km from centre)
Big Apple Bagels image
9
Big Apple Bagels
Bagel shop
Counter-serve chain for coffee, sandwiches & basic breakfast fare including muffins & bagels.
$ $$$
4.70 (99 reviews) (~43.33 km from centre)
Mr. Submarine image
10
Mr. Submarine
Sandwich shop
Counter-serve chain for sub sandwiches (including corned beef & roast beef), plus salads & soups.
$ $$$
4.60 (106 reviews) (~30.07 km from centre)
Millgate General Store image
11
Millgate General Store
Convenience store
4.60 (70 reviews) (~38.01 km from centre)
Lake Forest Food & Wine image
12
Lake Forest Food & Wine
American restaurant
$$ $$
4.60 (69 reviews) (~30.65 km from centre)
Once Upon A Deli image
13
Once Upon A Deli
Sandwich shop
👍👍 TBR, The Brutal Review, an eat-and-tell about a really good deli whose soups I can't wait to try. 6/14/2022: First visit. I only bought some nice, soft, big, doughy, pleasingly mild-flavored onion and garlic bagels. They were very-very-good enough for a return. Staff was genuinely great: polite, ho...
4.60 (59 reviews) (~43.16 km from centre)
West Town Bakery image
14
West Town Bakery
Bakery
👍👍 Great staff and food. They have a large bar in the middle with booths and bar stools around the outside. Also a big patio for summer. We came for breakfast - they had coffee, tea, cinnamon rolls, breakfast sandwiches, muffins and donuts. Lots of cake balls. Cookies and cakes. For lunch they have sa...
4.60 (34 reviews) (~41.96 km from centre)
Upper Crust Bagels - Northbrook image
15
Upper Crust Bagels - Northbrook
Bagel shop
👍👍 Grew up in NY always in search of a good bagel and I found it here. I would post a picture but I ate it too fast.
$$ $$
4.50 (88 reviews) (~43.27 km from centre)
Adam's Sandwich Shop image
16
Adam's Sandwich Shop
Sandwich shop
👍👍 Been waiting for this spot to open! The shop is clean, well merchandised, and nice decor. They sell goodies like pastries and pierogi's! And as for the sandwiches...the bread is fire! Nice size and fresh ingredients. It's unfortunate this new business received a 1 star because of the hours of opera...
4.50 (66 reviews) (~40.53 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Pleasant Prairie

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )