1
The Trattoria
Italian restaurant
Rustic Italian fare with a seasonal twist headlines at this cash-only, simple BYOB.
$$ $$
4.80 (281 reviews)
2
Ciro's
Italian restaurant
No-nonsense Italian eatery lures locals with hearty red-sauce dishes, weekly specials & a full bar.
$$ $$
4.60 (418 reviews)
3
Villa Olivetti
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Favorite restaurant ever! My husband and I love love love this place. We went here for one of our first Valentine’s Day, during 2020 covid, right after we got engaged, our birthdays, anniversaries, etc. We recommend this place to all of our family and friends. My parents actually just went for the f...
$$ $$
4.60 (378 reviews)
4
Steve's Piccola Bussola III
Italian restaurant
Easygoing destination with a warm vibe offering hearty servings of old-school Italian fare.
$$ $$
4.60 (316 reviews)
5
Cafe Red
New American restaurant
Warm, woodsy spot with a full bar for Italian fare & creative takes on American eats.
$$ $$
4.60 (301 reviews)
7
La Famiglia
Italian restaurant
Local chainlet of warm restaurants with homey Italian food served in portions meant for sharing.
$$ $$
4.50 (807 reviews)
8
Osteria Umbra
Italian restaurant
👍👍 After hearing one recommendation after another from family and friends we finally got to try Osteria Umbra for a special occasion and it lived up to expectations. Our waitress, Jennifer, was charming and professional; she made us feel welcome and at home like the rest of the staff who took time to o...
4.50 (437 reviews)
9
Ciro's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
😠 We ordered and picked up from Ciro’s tonight, and to say I’m disappointed would be an understatement. The Buffalo slices had no Buffalo sauce and I’ve never had a greasier grandma slice in my life. Overall, the pizza tasted similar to dominos. For the amount that we spent, I was expecting so much mo...
$ $$$
4.50 (415 reviews)
10
Giorgios
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 I Reallllllly liked the meatballs in my meatball hero, but the bread wasnt as robust as I would have liked. The taste if a meatball and the consistancy of the meatball along with the gravy are much more important than the bread. I only wish there was a bit more texture and crust on the bread.
$ $$$
4.50 (303 reviews)
11
Villa Sorrento
Italian restaurant
Traditional eatery offering Italian staples & a fixed-price menu in an atmospheric, candlelit room.
$$ $$
4.50 (271 reviews)
12
Sal's Ristorante & Bar
Italian restaurant
Family-friendly option for traditional Italian dining, with a cocktail lounge, local art & a patio.
$$ $$
4.50 (249 reviews)
13
Patio Pizza
Pizza restaurant
🫤 My daughter wanted to celebrate her latest abortion with a pizza party for the neighborhood children. This place refused to deliver! But I went and picked it up anyhow. Gotta say that make some very good pizza! I was pleasantly surprised, plus...I got a veteran discount!
$$ $$
4.50 (240 reviews)
14
ST. JAMES PIZZA & PASTA
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 I love this pizzeria. They make the best Sicilian slices.
Ah, the Sicilian slices! Thick, pillowy, and generously topped, they transport you straight to the streets of Palermo. The crust is golden and crispy on the outside, yet soft and doughy within. The tomato sauce is robust, and the cheese—oh, t...
$ $$$
4.50 (231 reviews)
15
Don Jono's
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Still my favorite hole in the wall!
Kids #1 favorite pizza shop too. Always a special day when we stop here
$ $$$
4.50 (160 reviews)
16
Three Bambino's
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Great pizza! My personal favorite is the chicken cesar pie, it is the best salad pizza in the area. I also love the peperoni rolls. You can't go wrong here!
$ $$$
4.50 (121 reviews)
17
Patrizia's of Hauppauge
Italian restaurant
😠 WORSE chicken parmesan thin and poorly made, taste like it was made 2 days ago and reheated we couldn’t even eat it! But they charged us basically $25 the Alfredo pasta didn’t taste like alfredo sauce at all! Taste like milk and it was cheesy looking, worse $50 ever spent. The best part was the BREA...
$$ $$
4.40 (1K reviews)
18
Spuntino St. James
Restaurant
👍👍 Had calamari very good, not too greasy. Toast coconut martini just right, nice and strong. Chicken Sorentino also very tasty. Alfredo was a very good waiter, asked us many times if everything was good and can I get you anything else.
$$ $$
4.40 (370 reviews)
19
Pietro Cucina Italiana
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Amazing food. Delicious salad, had a great dressing. Felt fresh and light. The dinners were a good portion. Had the best pasta I have had in a very long time. The sangria was not too sweet. And the limencello was out of this world and homemade. Every one gets a shot before you get the bill. Brillian...
4.40 (271 reviews)
20
Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Easygoing eatery offering a mix of pizza styles & traditional Italian mains, plus a bar & take-out.
$$ $$
4.30 (492 reviews)