Top rated Jewelers in Smithtown, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Jewelers in Smithtown

Experience the best that Smithtown has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 129 places from Jeweler category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Smithtown

SVS Fine Jewelry - Long Island. NY

Jewelry store

Jewelry shop featuring engagement rings with customizable designs, plus watches & other fine pieces.

5.00 (1.6K reviews) (~44.77 km from centre)

Milano and Son Jewelry

Jewelry store

👍👍 My first time shopping here! Raphael and Joe are great!!! My daughter wanted a hibiscus pendant. We looked everywhere and no other place had it. Raphael found it and ordered it for us. He said it would take 2 weeks and it came early. It was PERFECT!! Not only were they knowledgeable about the j...

5.00 (1.2K reviews) (~30.79 km from centre)

Landsberg Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 Landsberg Jewelers is wonderful family business that we have been going to for many years. They have an amazing selection of beautiful jewelry. They are incredibly talented jewelers, who can also help you design a piece of jewelry that works for you. They are creative and clearly take great pride i...

$$$ $

5.00 (820 reviews) (~43.67 km from centre)

OKG Jewelry

Jeweler

Family-owned shop since 1969 with designer fine jewelry & watch lines, plus repairs & custom pieces.

5.00 (503 reviews) (~45.38 km from centre)

Frassanito Jewelers

Jewelry store

Fine jewelry store offering rings, necklaces, bracelets & earrings in traditional & designer styles.

5.00 (491 reviews) (~19.01 km from centre)

Henry C Reid & Son Jewelers

Jewelry store

Established locale selling engagement rings, wedding bands & other jewelry, plus watches & gifts.

5.00 (331 reviews) (~32.06 km from centre)

Manhasset Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 I saw many great reviews for Jack on Facebook and Google. I had been looking for a jeweler I could trust with my special pieces. Jack is all that I read about him. He's pleasant, knowledgeable, trustworthy, and more. My beautiful bracelets have been securely fastened and cleaned to pristine cond...

5.00 (301 reviews) (~42.48 km from centre)

Nuha Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 I picked up my engagement ring at Nuha two weeks ago and have been wanting to write this review ever since. I had to wait until my surprise proposal this week. Buying a ring is a stressful experience and it was for me up until I walked into Nuha. I was sitting at my allergist appointment in Hicksvil...

5.00 (261 reviews) (~26.56 km from centre)

The Karat Shop

Jeweler

👍👍 Today I went to pick up my engagement ring and it was perfect! The whole staff was helpful and the owner gave me honest advice, and helped me make changes to the setting that made it perfect. The whole experience was wonderful and I never felt I was being forced out of my price range that I original...

5.00 (191 reviews) (~18.18 km from centre)

Renato's Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 Just picked up my jewelry from Renato and I am thrilled! For 20+ years he has been my go-to guy and I have always been pleased with the outcome - whether it has been a new creation made from my own stones (drop earrings and Huggies and a necklace), a redesign (a beaded necklace made into bracelets)...

5.00 (165 reviews) (~32.58 km from centre)

TWO by LONDON

Jeweler

5.00 (160 reviews) (~40.23 km from centre)

Bolila Jewelry

Jeweler

👍👍 Very Nice Jewelry Store, this was my first time in a jewelry store alone. Im 17 , i was getting a gift for my mom. There was a very nice Eastern European lady that helped me select the perfect gift for my mom without breaking the bank. My mom loved the gift. Im very happy with my experience. Great p...

5.00 (146 reviews) (~34.23 km from centre)

Steven Fox Jewelry

Jewelry store

Locally owned showroom offering designer, estate & custom jewelry, plus repairs in a polished venue.

5.00 (137 reviews) (~40.53 km from centre)

Keepsake Diamonds Corp.

Jewelry store

👍👍 You cannot go wrong shopping at Keepsake. John, the owner, is so incredibly knowledgeable you’ll feel like you learn something new every time you visit there. He was able to fix my engagement ring…not only fix the problem with the setting but give me the proper setting I should have had all along. H...

5.00 (121 reviews) (~7.61 km from centre)

Starflower Jewelry

Jeweler

👍👍 Absolutely 10 stars! The customer service Cait gives along with the entire team is astounding.. something you truly don’t see anymore. Pleasant atmosphere, honest, good prices, amazing work! My neckless in picture broke from only a month of wearing it. I walked in expecting it to be soldered back to...

5.00 (115 reviews) (~15.45 km from centre)

Unicorn Jewels Inc

Jewelry store

👍👍 They have been my jeweler for over 35 years. I trust them with my redesigns on my jewelry , and with everything I purchase. 100% honest people. I have had Denise make a few custom pieces for me. I have never been disappointed. Unicorn Jewelers are # 1 in my book and i have many friends that use the...

5.00 (108 reviews) (~45.48 km from centre)

LIV Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 Had an amazing experience with Ron and making a engagement ring. He was so knowledgeable and helpful with all our questions and was able to get us the perfect piece right in our price range. Super honest and welcoming and really worked hard and quickly to get us the perfect ring. Would absolutely su...

5.00 (101 reviews) (~19.03 km from centre)

Collectors Coins & Jewelry of Baldwin

Jewelry buyer

👍👍 My name is Elmer I came today on the 29th of November and I came to sell my coins and everything went great these guys are awesome great vibes

5.00 (99 reviews) (~40.31 km from centre)

Wallach Jewelry Designs

Jewelry store

👍👍 Bought our engagement ring here. Custom job, outstanding results. Will be back for the bands, for sure. Steven and Gina are both incredibly charming and will take massively good care of you, going above and beyond to you get what you want. Would recommend this place to anyone.

5.00 (97 reviews) (~47.78 km from centre)

Zaltas Fine Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 Kathy helped me create the perfect engagement ring for my girlfriend (now fiancé). I asked her to help me replace the diamond on a vintage engagement ring, which is very sentimental to my fiancé's family. She took the time to educate me on the diamonds and presented a variety of options. Once we pic...

5.00 (91 reviews) (~45.32 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Jewelers in Smithtown, United States