Top rated Jewelry stores in Smithtown, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Jewelry stores in Smithtown

Experience the best that Smithtown has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 279 places from Jewelry store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Smithtown

SVS Fine Jewelry - Long Island. NY

Jewelry store

Jewelry shop featuring engagement rings with customizable designs, plus watches & other fine pieces.

5.00 (1.6K reviews) (~44.77 km from centre)

Milano and Son Jewelry

Jewelry store

👍👍 My first time shopping here! Raphael and Joe are great!!! My daughter wanted a hibiscus pendant. We looked everywhere and no other place had it. Raphael found it and ordered it for us. He said it would take 2 weeks and it came early. It was PERFECT!! Not only were they knowledgeable about the j...

5.00 (1.2K reviews) (~30.79 km from centre)

Kravit Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 THE BEST EXPERIENCE PERIOD! I purchased my first Rolex from Trish and I could not have had a better experience! Trish and the Kravit staff were extremely welcoming, patient, and professional. It felt as though I was speaking to a long time friend and Trish made sure to make this an unforgettable exp...

5.00 (1K reviews) (~44.44 km from centre)

Landsberg Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 Landsberg Jewelers is wonderful family business that we have been going to for many years. They have an amazing selection of beautiful jewelry. They are incredibly talented jewelers, who can also help you design a piece of jewelry that works for you. They are creative and clearly take great pride i...

$$$ $

5.00 (820 reviews) (~43.67 km from centre)

Manfredi Jewels

Watch store

Classy, long-running boutique offering a selection of fine jewelry & designer watches.

5.00 (557 reviews) (~40.58 km from centre)

OKG Jewelry

Jeweler

Family-owned shop since 1969 with designer fine jewelry & watch lines, plus repairs & custom pieces.

5.00 (506 reviews) (~45.38 km from centre)

Frassanito Jewelers

Jewelry store

Fine jewelry store offering rings, necklaces, bracelets & earrings in traditional & designer styles.

5.00 (491 reviews) (~19.01 km from centre)

Fine Jewelry by Stacey

Jewelry store

👍👍 Visited Solomon Jewelers Willis Avenue location in order to have a stone replaced in my diamond ring.. the stone was an unusual slightly oval shape..quite out of the ordinary.. and not easy to find.. but.. amazingly.. Stacy.. the owner,assured me she would try her best!!! Did she ever!!! I picked up...

5.00 (472 reviews) (~38.78 km from centre)

Cellini Design Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 I recently had the pleasure of entrusting my treasured vintage watch to Cellini Jewelers for repair, and I am absolutely thrilled with the exceptional service and craftsmanship I received. They carefully examined my grandfather’s 1960s omega constellation watch and provided me with a detailed expla...

5.00 (472 reviews) (~47.27 km from centre)

Manfredi Jewels

Watch store

👍👍 I've been buying luxury watches for 20 years. I've seldom if ever had an experience that was as warm or welcoming as what I received at Manfredi. A truly exceptional group.

5.00 (366 reviews) (~40.62 km from centre)

Henry C Reid & Son Jewelers

Jewelry store

Established locale selling engagement rings, wedding bands & other jewelry, plus watches & gifts.

5.00 (331 reviews) (~32.06 km from centre)

Elegant Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 Mike and Elegant Jewelers were exactly what I needed when looking for a jeweler to craft a surprise engagement ring for my now fiancé. He had great suggestions and advice, was thorough, and extremely accommodating — if requested, he made things happen immediately. I admit I had been a bit demanding...

5.00 (328 reviews) (~23.63 km from centre)

Maddy Fine Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 I got a necklace for my wife for our anniversary. It is a diamond necklace and my wife absolutely loved it. We got the best price here after shopping at multiple stores. My wife wears this necklace every day. We are so happy with Maddy fine jewelers. They are truly the best.

5.00 (295 reviews) (~23.53 km from centre)

Nuha Jewelers

Jeweler

👍👍 I picked up my engagement ring at Nuha two weeks ago and have been wanting to write this review ever since. I had to wait until my surprise proposal this week. Buying a ring is a stressful experience and it was for me up until I walked into Nuha. I was sitting at my allergist appointment in Hicksvil...

5.00 (261 reviews) (~26.56 km from centre)

Diamond Designs

Jewelry store

👍👍 I had a wonderful experience with Diamond Designs. I spent a good amount of time visiting many vendors and comparing options. Joe was great to talk through options with, very knowledgeable, and gave great recommendations based on what I was interested in. Prices were very competitive (and I really c...

5.00 (228 reviews) (~47.02 km from centre)

Lana's Jewelry

Jewelry store

👍👍 I haven't worn my engagement ring in years as it was too small. My rings came back brand new and sparkling! Love wearing them again. Eddie was pleasant, trustworthy professional and price was reasonable. I would highly recommend Lana's jewelry. And my son got a great chain too! It was a great...

5.00 (224 reviews) (~31.21 km from centre)

Michaels Jewelry Designs

Jewelry store

👍👍 Good guy. here cause of you getting a collaboration. your a nice person, I’m not in the area but if people are in the area please visit.

5.00 (211 reviews) (~43.49 km from centre)

A.J. Klein Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 This place has some of the best customer service I've experienced in a long time. I came in with my wife's gold bracelet that had a damaged pin. It was detached on one end leaving it vulnerable to complete detachment and possible loss. The in house jewler was able to fix it in short order for a pric...

5.00 (196 reviews) (~45.8 km from centre)

Charles Krypell Fine Jewelry

Jewelry store

👍👍 We have purchased my wife’s engagement ring, my wife’s wedding ring, my wedding ring, and most recently pearl earrings for my mother for Christmas. Charles Krypell has an excellent selection of top quality jewelry and educate you on the finest detail of each piece. The entire experience is flawless...

5.00 (191 reviews) (~36.32 km from centre)

The Karat Shop

Jeweler

👍👍 Today I went to pick up my engagement ring and it was perfect! The whole staff was helpful and the owner gave me honest advice, and helped me make changes to the setting that made it perfect. The whole experience was wonderful and I never felt I was being forced out of my price range that I original...

5.00 (191 reviews) (~18.18 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Jewelry stores in Smithtown, United States