Hidden gems - Hotels in Toms River, United States not to miss (Updated March, 2024)

Hidden gems: Hotels in Toms River

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Toms River. This list contains 502 places from Hotel category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Toms River

Maurrocks BnB

Bed & breakfast

Casual rooms with art deco furnishings in a warm B&B offering free Wi-Fi & parking, plus gardens.

5.00 (141 reviews) (~163.03 km from centre)

Fathoms Hotel & Marina

Hotel

👍👍 Fathoms is a precious gem in the Port Washington area. While a small property with only six rooms, it is part of a larger residential property on the water’s edge with beautiful views. The rooms are spacious and immaculately clean. Every detail is perfect, right down to the high-end amenities. The l...

5.00 (110 reviews) (~106.04 km from centre)

Miss Molly's Inn Bed & Breakfast

Bed & breakfast

Victorian-era B&B with homemade breakfast & afternoon tea, plus a library & use of beach gear.

5.00 (92 reviews) (~246.41 km from centre)

Serenité Private Residence Club

Club

👍👍 Serenite’ is our home away from home! We always have the best experience during our stay. Liz and the entire staff are always so accommodating. We always receive such a warm welcome and are so happy to be apart of the serenite’ family!

5.00 (91 reviews) (~157.44 km from centre)

The Roundtree, Amagansett

Hotel

👍👍 Spent a truly perfect 4th of July vaccation at The Roundtree. Can't say enough great things about it. Flawless, but the service is what particularly stands out: on par with luxury hotel service in Europe. We stayed for 5 days and I can't find a single thing to complain about. Everyone we worked with...

5.00 (81 reviews) (~207.92 km from centre)

Guild House Hotel

Hotel

👍👍 My husband and I stayed here on our honeymoon. We stayed in room Florence. It was incredible. The hotel is so quaint and gorgeous. I love the character of the room, with a tall mirror, a giant wardrobe, and lovely little sitting areas. The bathroom was great too, the shower was fantastic and they ga...

5.00 (73 reviews) (~82.33 km from centre)

Watergrasshill Bed & Breakfast

Bed & breakfast

Polished, country-style rooms in an updated 19th-century farmhouse offering mountain views.

5.00 (68 reviews) (~193.8 km from centre)

The Gateway at Pine Hill

Bed & breakfast

European-style B&B featuring a cozy living room with a wood stove, plus a deck, patio & free Wi-Fi.

5.00 (65 reviews) (~245.01 km from centre)

Galvanized America Inn and Art Gallery

Bed & breakfast

5.00 (64 reviews) (~95.72 km from centre)

Mad Men Beach House

Holiday home

5.00 (51 reviews) (~184.14 km from centre)

Seven - resort style boutique b&b on Shelter Island

Bed & breakfast

Upscale B&B in a 1902 farmhouse offering a porch & a furnished deck, plus a garden.

5.00 (51 reviews) (~199.07 km from centre)

Bethel Pastures Farm Bed & Breakfast

Bed & breakfast

Warm accommodations in a laid-back farmhouse B&B with BBQ areas, fire pits & hiking trails.

5.00 (51 reviews) (~210.27 km from centre)

Reclaimed Motel

Hotel

👍👍 A+++ an absolute must!! Perfect city getaway ❤️ Not only does this motel offer exceptional views, zen getaway vibes and super funky decor, the local owners have thought of absolutely everything. For example: * Thoughtful snacks and refreshments * Record player in EVERY ROOM which is super easy to u...

5.00 (51 reviews) (~231.61 km from centre)

YOWIE (Hotel & Shop)

Hotel

👍👍 Simply extraordinary! We had an amazing weekend stay and the staff was so gracious and accommodating. Every detail of the cafe, boutique, and hotel is beyond. Huge congrats to Shannon + team! Can’t imagine staying anywhere else in Philly :)

5.00 (50 reviews) (~80.98 km from centre)

Villa Signor

Hotel

5.00 (49 reviews) (~246.9 km from centre)

La Colina

Hotel

👍👍 You must visit this beautiful Spanish style country estate! The grounds, the house, and casitas are absolutely stunning! From the moment you are greeted by your lovely hosts Stacey and Andrew in a beautifully refurbished airstream you will be transported into a different time. The views and pool ar...

5.00 (48 reviews) (~161.19 km from centre)

West Point Foundry Bed and Breakfast

Bed & breakfast

👍👍 Our stay at West Point Foundry was awesome. The house is such a peaceful place for a weekend getaway and has beautiful views of the Hudson. Marianne, David, and Leigh Ann were great hosts. They've put a lot of thought into renovations by maintaining the historical elements while ensuring comfort for...

5.00 (45 reviews) (~163.81 km from centre)

Kestrel Hotel - Fishtown

Hotel

5.00 (44 reviews) (~80.03 km from centre)

Harbor View Landing

Hotel

👍👍 The grounds are beautiful and the decor in the cottages is updated and bright. The Nantucket cottage was spacious and perfect for our family. And the views to the water when you wake up are idyllic! Our kids also loved using the paddle boards and kayaks....and the nighttime s’mores. All in all, a wo...

5.00 (44 reviews) (~243.18 km from centre)

Evergreen Inn Bed & Breakfast

Bed & breakfast

Traditional rooms, plus a stream, an outdoor pool, a flagstone patio & free hot breakfast.

5.00 (43 reviews) (~190.9 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Hotels in Toms River, United States