Hidden gems - Pie shops in Toms River, United States not to miss (Updated March, 2024)

Hidden gems: Pie shops in Toms River

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Toms River. This list contains 16 places from Pie shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Toms River

Lancaster Pie & Coffee

Pie shop

👍👍 This little adorable shop is so inviting. The owners were a delight and made you feel as if you were the most important person. They wanted to know you and share their love of pies with you. We got pies to go and ate a waffle there. The waffle with fruit was to die for. I cannot wait to go back!

5.00 (139 reviews) (~180.14 km from centre)

Paullet's Bakery

Bakery

5.00 (21 reviews) (~214.42 km from centre)

Amy's Custom Cakery

Cake shop

4.90 (101 reviews) (~226.47 km from centre)

PIE+TART

Pie shop

👍👍 Heaven for your taste buds, this pie and tart shop is a neighborhood gem. There are so many delicious choices, you can’t go wrong. The handheld Aussie meat pie was fantastic, and I have a freezer full of more to try. Coffee options , savory and sweet pies, friendly service, adorable setup. It’s stre...

4.90 (67 reviews) (~118.95 km from centre)

Kirshenbaum Baking Co.

Bakery

👍👍 Went for the first time today (Aug 18, 2023). Really impressed. Pastry was excellent. Served on a ceramic plate and metal fork. I only note that because it’s hard to come by some actual silverware and plates in a cafe. Very comfortable and high-quality furniture. Clean, high ceilings, soothing decor...

$$ $$

4.90 (58 reviews) (~78.74 km from centre)

Little Susie’s Coffee & Pie

Coffee shop

👍👍 One day I was strolling along the streets of Philadelphia. The usual. Making sure people know that “I’m walk-in’ here!” Helping non Philadelphians feel welcome, politely asking them questions like “why are you here?”. “Who roots for the RedSucks”. And “If you’re not an Eagles fan, how do you look y...

4.90 (56 reviews) (~80.74 km from centre)

Noble Pies

Pie shop

$$ $$

4.80 (44 reviews) (~128.16 km from centre)

Hearth Baker

Bakery

👍 Finally getting in to check this place out. It's a cozy place. Everything looks great. Reasonably priced. The sourdough bread is delicious.

$ $$$

4.70 (144 reviews) (~97.52 km from centre)

Bonheur Ice Cream and Pie

Ice cream shop

4.70 (135 reviews) (~207.89 km from centre)

The Bakery Nook

Bakery

👍👍 Back in June of 2022, was my Bridal Shower! My mom & the bridesmaids ended up getting my shower cake from the Bakery Nook- i’m pretty picky with cake, but it was spot on, red velvet with a nice buttercream not to sweet not to heavy icing! It was perfect ! I would recommend this place to anyone local...

$$ $$

4.70 (68 reviews) (~140.27 km from centre)

Kensington Pies

Bakery

👍👍 Found this establishment after reading an article about the owner bringing English meat pies into our area. Had a great chat with the owner and picked up four meat pies, two Cornish pasties and a scotch egg. All were delicious. We'll definitely return for more!

$$ $$

4.70 (52 reviews) (~100.31 km from centre)

The Bakery of Southbury

Bakery

4.60 (101 reviews) (~188.78 km from centre)

Mazza's Market and Coffee House

Coffee shop

😠 The food was good and the coffee was okay. It was an interesting, unique place. It's adorable actually, and I was very excited when I found it. However when I sat down to eat, I noticed that there were very prominently displayed Trump themed soda bottles (complete with racial slur). Honestly, I don'...

$ $$$

4.60 (64 reviews) (~71.84 km from centre)

The Baker's Workshop - Suffolk Community College Culinary Arts Center is open to the public while school is in session!

Bakery

😐 Look like is going to be a great school I'm here to see if I can take some classes Wish me luck.

4.60 (12 reviews) (~168.48 km from centre)

Noble Pies Bakery & Cafe

Pie shop

👍👍 When all you make is pies you really make some amazing pies. Worth checking out, I had the apple pie and buffalo chicken pie. They are denser than they look, we got a large and small and the small was perfect for two. Great staff, she helped us decide.

$$ $$

4.50 (70 reviews) (~122.39 km from centre)

Betty Bakery

Coffee shop

👍👍 The coffee was good and the pumpkin bread was delicious!

4.50 (36 reviews) (~80.81 km from centre)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Pie shops in Toms River, United States