1
Atlantis Diner
Diner
😠 Where do I begin my husband and I were utterly shocked when we found out our favorite waiter is no longer there, we found out the daytime manager wrongfully fired him to make room for someone she knew, out of all people one of the sweetest young waiters we ever met was let go. We stopped going there...
$$ $$
4.20 (1.1K reviews)
2
Besito Mexican Restaurant - West Islip NY
Mexican restaurant
👍 Staff was lovely, food was good, the restaurant was lovely inside. All around good experience! The shrimp empanadas were really really good!
$$ $$
4.50 (1K reviews)
3
Chuck E. Cheese
Pizza restaurant
Kid-friendly chain known for its arcade games, pizza parties, play zones & mouse mascot.
$$ $$
4.30 (954 reviews)
4
Brownstones Coffee West Islip
Breakfast restaurant
👍👍 Love all the locations but come here the most. Great staff, great food, good time! They’re super quick and as a Muslim I have a hard time finding places with no cross contamination esp in diners. I’ve never found meat in my eggs, and always enjoy the drinks. The food is delish, even their vegetarian...
$$ $$
4.60 (870 reviews)
5
McDonald's
Fast food restaurant
Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.
$ $$$
3.90 (860 reviews)
6
Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta
European restaurant
🫤 The food here isn't bad. Ambiance could be much much better especially for a family oriented restaurant/pizza shop. Yankees and Mets both having great seasons with a game on every day yet me or my group is forced to watch Tucker Carlson looking down upon us from the big screen TV every time I try to...
$ $$$
4.50 (429 reviews)
7
Primi Italian Steakhouse
Steak house
👍👍 Loved the place and the ambience. Service was top notch super attentive and personable.
We had the porterhouse, 2 filler mingnos, the artichoke and octopus. Everything was cooked to perfection except the octopus that I like a bit more charred (personal taste).
Drinks - do try the dirty blue olive...
$$$ $
4.30 (401 reviews)
8
Farrell's of Brooklyn
Bar & grill
Upbeat American sports bar & grill offering lunch & dinner, plus happy hour during the week.
$$ $$
4.40 (330 reviews)
9
Crispino's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Omg the best pizzas hands down! We aren’t locals in the area, we were just visiting, and we just walked in with 6 hungry kids and 3 adults.
The front desk girl was so sweet and kind, and everyone was very friendly even though we had loud and messy kids. I really appreciate their kindness and patienc...
$$ $$
4.50 (286 reviews)
10
Long River
Chinese restaurant
Relaxed sit-down Chinese restaurant with take-out counter also offers sushi & Thai curries.
$$ $$
4.00 (274 reviews)
11
Dunkin'
Coffee shop
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
$ $$$
3.50 (257 reviews)
12
Victorio II Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Excellent customer service. Tasty pizza. Clean restaurant. BBQ chicken slice was delish!
$ $$$
4.30 (238 reviews)
13
Bang Bang Burritos
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 I always go for the Buffalo chicken tacos, and there quesadilla is always on point. The burritos are massive, and they basically but anything in them. There menu is huge, and service was good. Everytime I pass through I always have to stop.
$$ $$
4.30 (172 reviews)
14
Secatogue Brewing Company
Brewery
👍👍 Came here as a part of their Wednesday night trivia night special which was an absolute blast. The selection of beers changes periodically, but seems to have a decent focus on IPAs for the most part, but they have other options available if that's not your jive. I got the Gorilla Cake stout, which w...
$$ $$
4.60 (153 reviews)
15
Bella Cucina
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 First and foremost, the owners are absolute sweethearts. Anytime you walk in the gentleman are so welcoming and friendly. I personally recommend the pene alla vodka pizza, it’s my favorite!! Also the mozzarella sticks are amazing too!!
$$ $$
4.50 (135 reviews)
16
Dunkin'
Coffee shop
Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.
$ $$$
3.70 (127 reviews)
17
Four Season Kitchen
Chinese restaurant
👍👍 People here are super nice. The food is always good. The wonton soup is delicious. The wontons are very big and filling.
4.00 (124 reviews)
18
Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering
Pizza restaurant
😠 For +/- past 10 yrs, we’ve ordered our meatball parm heroes here, once a month or so, driving past 4 closer pizza places. (They were THAT good!) Last night we were given the wrong order but, rather than refund our money for OUR trouble when we returned uneaten eggplant parm heroes to pick up correct...
$ $$$
3.90 (118 reviews)
19
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks of West Islip
Fast food restaurant
😐 Cheesesteak was ok. Fries were meh. $24 for a large cheesesteak, fries and a soda felt overpriced for the quality.
$ $$$
4.40 (106 reviews)
20
Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
Italian restaurant
Local counter-serve chain that's a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats.
$ $$$
4.00 (104 reviews)