Top rated Bagel shops in Indiana to elevate your visit (Updated November, 2023)

Top rated Bagel shops in Indiana

Experience the best that Indiana has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 132 places from Bagel shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Bagel Girls

Bagel shop

👍👍 This place is open early (7am) so I can get bagels before work!! Bagels were soft inside and crusty outside. I just got a house made schmear on my toasted bagel, but my pics include the breakfast and lunch menus. Glad to have another breakfast/lunch option in downtown Corydon.

5.00 (34 reviews)

The Eleventh House

Coffee shop

😠 Having been a loyal customer for the past couple of years, I was excited to visit their new location on 3rd Street now that they have opened up and moved in. We ordered the usual things. Diner egg and cheese bagels with avocado, an iced masala chai latte, and a good karma. Frankly, we were really...

4.90 (115 reviews)

Big Apple Bagels

Bagel shop

Counter-serve chain for coffee, sandwiches & basic breakfast fare including muffins & bagels.

$ $$$

4.80 (533 reviews)

Gables Bagels

Bagel shop

👍👍 Great bangles! I tried the ancient grain with cream cheese and lox loaded. Best I've ever had!

$ $$$

4.80 (151 reviews)

Sophie's Bagels

Bagel shop

4.80 (136 reviews)

Perfect Twist Pretzels

Restaurant

👍👍 This cute little shop is conveniently located in Coppes Commons. The employees are all friendly and helpful. They have pretzels and pretzel pockets, so they can be good for a meal, a snack, or dessert. It has a cozy atmosphere with nice decor. Their prices are great too! It is overall a really nice...

$ $$$

4.80 (120 reviews)

Bean Me Up Roastery & Cafe

Cafe

👍👍 My first time at Bean Me Up was GREAT! Great customer service & the cold brew is the best cold brew I’ve ever had. Everything tasted super fresh. The bacon egg & pepper jack was soo good! Great way to start my morning. I will definitely be back asap. I finished my coffee before I even went into work...

4.80 (109 reviews)

Heritage Meeting House

Coffee shop

👍👍 The place smells fantastic and is tangibly cozy. Book selection is genuinely decent: mythology, religion, mammals, travel, reference, classics, YA, and more. They have local crafts and tiny potted plants you can buy. Seasonal beverages include peppermint, eggnog, and gingerbread lattes. Their year...

4.80 (66 reviews)

Ripple Bagel and Deli

Bagel shop

Compact counter-serve stop featuring a variety of steamed bagel sandwiches, plus soups & salads.

$ $$$

4.70 (630 reviews)

Davey's Delicious Bagels

Bakery

🫤 After reading all of the great reviews, I decided to place an order since I'm visiting from out of town. I have no idea how people could rate this place so high. I ordered 4 bagels, toasted, 3 with cream cheese, and one with butter. For the price that they charge, $2 extra per bagel for cream chees...

$ $$$

4.70 (576 reviews)

The French Press Coffee Co.

Coffee shop

👍👍 Wonderfully friendly staff and quality food. Had a very simple but very good Ham, Egg, Cheese Panini and a Med Roast Drip. Coffee offerings were spot on. Grateful to have a quaint and quality local shop to go to. Call ahead to check the hours—website is not correct. That said, looks like Google Maps...

$$ $$

4.70 (299 reviews)

Bearded Bagel

Bagel shop

👍👍 Bearded Bagel 🥯 is one of those upstarts that makes you feel right at home in their cozy digs. Starting out from a food truck 2 years ago, this place has the food truck feel without standing out in the blistering Indiana cold. I had the Hangover Helper bagel, which had eggs, a bunch of cheese, baco...

$ $$$

4.70 (299 reviews)