We had never been to Blue Sophia and was sent there by Theo Alexander from Liquid 8 Pawn Shop (Where we found great items). Theo told us Blue Sophia does their repairs and who to ask for. Sophia and Kim could not have been better people to talk with about a ring my wife was looking for. Sophia took the time to draw out the ring and price it. The next day Sophia and my wife took several diamond rings and made one beautiful custom diamond ring. The ring was not only way more than our expectations but the way Sophia laid out the ring was her idea. Between what my wife wanted and their experience we could not be any happier with Blue Sophia. We already have a few more ideas. Quality, Honest and Great company to deal with. They do not have ten stars on the rating but ten it is.

I live in Key West. Blue Sophia, Kim and Sophia, are fantastic people and very skilled craftsmen. The are very nice and do excellent work. The previous negative reviews are probably form a-holes. This is a great store, especially if you want custom made jewelry. They are very nice people as well. I have bought many pieces from them and was always blown away by the quality. Rob

I absolutely love Blue Sophia!! They made my beautiful engagement ring! I’m in love with my ring. They are very professional and patient with great communication! I highly recommend. Can’t wait to see how the wedding bands turn out!

This is the only Jeweler I personally use, They do beautiful work, The Jewelry is amazing. They really care about the quality, of the work they do. We live 7+ hours away, and still love the jewelry they have, the repairs they do, and the custom pieces they create..Thank you ,Blue Sophia Jewelry store.

I love them so much! I used to live in Key West and Sophie helped me with my wedding bands which are completely beautiful and amazing quality. I now live in Virginia Beach but I love their Jewerly so much that I’ve decided to continue buying from them!

Kim and Sophia are great people. They are kind, honest, and hard working. No matter how swamped they are, they always make time for customers. They have always gone out of their way for customers. They are my go to people for anything I need jewelry related. I don't trust anyone else to do quality work. If you're looking for quality/custom jewelry, watch battery replacement, or jewelry repair I highly recommend you go see them!! Keep in mind they are the best on the island so sometimes they get busy. Just be patient because quality work takes time just like good food.

Kim and Sophia are the nicest people, and their craftsmanship is unmatched. They custom made two nose rings for me, and we have purchased a few gorgeous pieces from them. We do not go anywhere else! Highly suggest!!!! They are the best!

We visit Key West almost every year for our anniversary. Over the years I have purchased many pieces for my wife... rings and earrings primarily, plus a few necklaces. There are two things I need to point out to show what an amazing place this is. First... if you are in their store for any length of time you will see the other jewelers in town bringing in pieces to be sized or modified in some way. Kim and Sophia are the experts in town, and the other jewelers know that. Second, my wife has very specific taste in jewelry (much more subdued than the large gaudier pieces everyone seems to stock). More times than I can count we have discussed what we want and they have modified something to make it EXACTLY what my wife likes. One time we were talking about earrings... Kim said they could take an infinity band (small diamonds all the way around) that we liked, use about 1/4 of it for each earring, then replace the missing half with a plain band. We ended up with earrings and a ring that matched (they used to be one piece!) and to this day those are her favorite pieces. They are also, by far, the best "clipping" of all her pierced-ear earrings. Obviously you can't get that kind of work done overnight, so twice we have paid for items that he later sent to us. They are perfectly honest and respectable and we have never had an issue. As others have said, they are also a very pleasant couple. We LOVE Blue Sophia!

Highly recommend Sophia beautiful jewelry. Bought a really nice diamond & emerald ring. I will definitely go back for more jewelry. Ty Sophia

Sophia is so talented in making her custom jewelry pieces! Sophia and Kim can create anything you would like in jewelry with beautiful results. Thank you so much!

Blue Sophia Jewelry is amazing!! We were just walking around Key West on 7/12/23 and stumbled upon this gem (lol) of a jeweler. Sophia and Kim really know jewelry!! Sophia custom made an absolutely stunning diamond cross for me in less than 24 hours. I've been wearing it since I got it, and I've gotten numerous compliments already! Ty for my brilliant diamond cross! Also, ty to my fabulous husband for buying me this gift! 💕. If you are in their area, stop in. You will not be disappointed.

These people are extremely talented jewelers with many successful outcomes. They came highly recommended and are extremely fair & honest about all aspects of your jewelry requests. They alway speak the truth and you can alway be guaranteed they will do whatever they tell a customer. I’m so happy with my mounted Atocha coins.