A delightful local cafe with a great selection of sandwiches and perfect toasties. Highlights: 1. Service!! This was first visit and clearly this is a local favourite. One of the staff there helped take my order while a local customer was catching a conversation at the counter. He even purposefully cleaned a table for me so I could sit comfortably. 2. Toastie!! The most perfect one I've tasted. I ordered the duck, fig jam and scallion. It's got a layer of crispy toasted cheese on the outside and gooey cheesy goodness on the inside. The bread is perfectly crisp. The coffee was also what you'd expect from a good cafe. Overall, I definitely recommend a visit and I will definitely be back. Thanks to the Three Blind Mice team!!

Get here and have a cheese toastie.. I feel like I’m doing it an injustice calling it a toastie cause it’s so good. Coffee is amazing, prob the best I’ve had. Can’t wait to come here for some pasta and wine on Thursday. They also have a cheese and meats selection which is great. Best prosciutto I’ve had outside of Italy.

The owners are ex-Penny's Cheese Shop in Potts Point, so you know it's gonna be good! The 5 cheese blend toastie with confit duck, fig and scallion ($16) - as balanced as a cheese toastie gets, nuanced with a touch of sweetness from fig, and the aroma of scallions. The salami piccante ($14.5) was also great. The cheese spilling out of both creates a lovely crispy cheesy lace around the edge of the sandwich which is amazing. On the way out, picked up a slice of the pumpkin cake ($6) on the counter and it was moist and lovely, although the main flavour is cinnamon - wish you could taste the pumpkin a little. June 2023: Picked up some meats and goodies for a charcuterie board and was grateful for Milan's excellent service. He was so kind as to slice my baguette for me too. The salami was peppery and delicious, proscuitto was beautiful and everything super fresh. Loved the breadsticks and their freshly baked carrot cake too.

Lovely cafe with friendly owners and staff! This place has amazing food. The simple cheese toastie has been elevated into an art form! Their version is absolutely delicious. They have specials which change regularly. The Ruben sandwich was fantastic and they had a truffle version of the toastie which was superb. I wish I was into day drinking as they would have been lovely with a glass of red. Alas, I had to do with their great coffee. If you prefer a long black but can’t stand the sour aftertaste most beans give, you will love their coffee!!! They have special night menus (Greek themed and such) and I would love to attend one. It’s a smallish space and I’m sure it fills up quickly. This makes me wish I lived closer. A lot closer…. Will definitely be back!

I recently had an experience at Three Blind Mice. I had five cheese blend toastie and confit duck, fig and scallion. Cheesy blend cheese inside and crispy toast outside. Definitely will go back for salami piccante and double smoked ham&pickle onion toastie.

Enjoyed the salami toastie and lovely environment. Will be back to buy some handmade pasta and cheeses. Wanted to buy some bread home but there were flies hanging out in the store so I hesitated - will review that another day!

Thank you very much for the christmas platters. They were delicious, you kindly did them the day before, and even separated the cheese from meat after I mentioned I was vegetarian. Thank you!

We had a meal here recently during a VIP night and the service was wonderful. The meals were too. The individual grazing platters were lovely & the beef cheek was incredible.