Top rated American restaurants in Old Toronto

Experience the best that Old Toronto has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 133 places from American restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


White Lily Diner image
1
White Lily Diner
Diner
Humble spot dishing out all-day breakfasts & deli sandwiches with house-smoked meats.
$$ $$
4.70 (1.3K reviews) (~2.7 km from centre)
Maple Leaf Tavern image
2
Maple Leaf Tavern
Canadian restaurant
Built in 1910, this wood-dominated space serves chops, steaks & fish, plus elevated comfort food.
$$$ $
4.60 (871 reviews) (~3.91 km from centre)
Illstyl3 Sammies image
3
Illstyl3 Sammies
Sandwich shop
👍👍 Can we talk about their portion size? The comments aren’t lying! So generous and worth the price. I ordered the Philly steak cheese combo and hands down got blown away by the tenderness of the meat. Ohhhh and the fries….. you don’t want to miss out on. Have to say, best sandwich shop I’ve ever tried...
4.60 (745 reviews) (~0.79 km from centre)
Canoe image
4
Canoe
Canadian restaurant
A stylish, swanky space on the 54th floor, with inventive Canadian cuisine & exceptional views.
$$$$
4.50 (3K reviews) (~0.7 km from centre)
The Carbon Bar image
5
The Carbon Bar
Barbecue restaurant
BBQ, Southern-inspired fare & cocktails in a casual space with artsy decor & plush banquettes.
$$ $$
4.50 (2.9K reviews) (~0.74 km from centre)
Ruth's Chris Steak House image
6
Ruth's Chris Steak House
Steak house
Outpost of upmarket steakhouse chain known for sizzling, butter-topped beef in an elegant setting
$$$$
4.50 (1.4K reviews) (~0.42 km from centre)
The Old York Tavern image
7
The Old York Tavern
American restaurant
Quaint neighbourhood tavern, offering small plates, brunch & dinner.
4.50 (707 reviews) (~2.23 km from centre)
Le Swan image
8
Le Swan
Restaurant
Handsome art-deco style French diner offering bistro classics & comfort fare plus wine & cocktails.
4.50 (703 reviews) (~2.66 km from centre)
Canadiana Grill By The Lake image
9
Canadiana Grill By The Lake
Restaurant
Warm & enduring family-run diner with round banquettes & a bar dishing up comfort favourites.
$ $$$
4.50 (452 reviews) (~9.6 km from centre)
Alice Restaurant & Bar image
10
Alice Restaurant & Bar
Restaurant
👍👍 This is a quaint and cozy restaurant with romantic vibes. The staff here are very friendly and nice. The restaurant has two floors and can cater to big parties and events too. They have a big patio in the back. My favorite dish here is the Mexican corn. How they make the Mexican corn is also pretty...
4.50 (124 reviews) (~2.08 km from centre)
Jer’s Filicanasian Restaurant image
11
Jer’s Filicanasian Restaurant
Filipino restaurant
👍👍 Randomly gave this restaurant a try never having eaten Filipino before. Pretty delicious, I wish I had tried it sooner.
4.50 (56 reviews) (~6.66 km from centre)
PLANTA image
12
PLANTA
Vegan restaurant
Internationally inspired plant-based dishes served in a stylish setting with soaring ceilings.
$$ $$
4.40 (3.5K reviews) (~1.91 km from centre)
Church's Texas Chicken image
13
Church's Texas Chicken
American restaurant
4.40 (1.1K reviews) (~1.51 km from centre)
Poke Guys image
14
Poke Guys
Hawaiian restaurant
Simple counter serve offering a variety of rice bowls topped with sashimi, vegetables & garnishes.
$ $$$
4.40 (1.1K reviews) (~0.15 km from centre)
Big Smoke Burger image
15
Big Smoke Burger
Hamburger restaurant
Creative burgers, hand-cut fries & shakes round out the menu at this chain with housemade sauces.
$$ $$
4.40 (991 reviews) (~0.75 km from centre)
Morton's The Steakhouse image
16
Morton's The Steakhouse
Restaurant
Upscale chain for aged prime beef, seafood & other traditional steakhouse fare in a clubby space.
$$$$
4.40 (760 reviews) (~1.97 km from centre)
ChickQueen image
17
ChickQueen
Chicken restaurant
😠 During my recent DoorDash order from Chick Queen, I encountered a disappointing incident. While enjoying my meal, I discovered two hairs in the burger, which was quite unappetizing. This was the worst experience of my life. Discovering hair in my food at Chick Queen was incredibly disappointing, an...
4.40 (576 reviews) (~0.52 km from centre)
Wow! Wing House image
18
Wow! Wing House
Chicken restaurant
👍👍 Price: $18 for delivery but worth it with a discount and free delivery. Still cheaper than other wing spots. Pickup would be the best value I think it's 16$ My experience: I was pleasantly surprised. I was pleased with the order and loved the addition of the chilli fries. The fresh spice pairs perf...
4.40 (140 reviews) (~2.95 km from centre)
Five Guys image
19
Five Guys
Fast food restaurant
Fast-food chain with made-to-order burgers, fries & hot dogs, plus free peanuts while you wait.
$$ $$
4.30 (2.4K reviews) (~0.47 km from centre)
Dukes Refresher image
20
Dukes Refresher
Bar & grill
Relaxed watering hole with table tennis, arcade games & a mini basketball court, plus a patio.
4.30 (1.8K reviews) (~1.04 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near Old Toronto

View all places in Canada

Last updated:
( )