1
Ortygia
Italian restaurant
Chef-run eatery delivers homestyle Sicilian specialties in colorfully cozy digs with a patio.
$$ $$
4.70 (362 reviews)
2
Arte Caffe
Italian restaurant
Charming, intimate restaurant featuring pizza, pasta & other Italian classics, plus patio seating.
$$ $$
4.70 (329 reviews)
3
San Remo Pizza & Pasta
Restaurant
Established pizza joint offering large New York-style pies & slices in an unfussy, compact interior.
$$ $$
4.60 (911 reviews)
4
Fav's Italian Cucina
Italian restaurant
Local stop favored for stromboli, homemade pastas & other Italian standards in cozy quarters.
$$ $$
4.60 (667 reviews)
6
Danny's Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Basic, cozy choice for New York-style pies, Italian standards, calzones & heros on garlic bread.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.6K reviews)
7
Casa Di Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Branch of a Buffalo, N.Y., mini-chain started in 1953 serving wings & pizzas in no-frills digs.
$$ $$
4.50 (1.1K reviews)
8
Wilder's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 First time visiting and could not have been more impressed. We visit the area every summer and had been looking for a new pizza place when I saw the reviews for Wilder's. They did not lie in their praise: the Garlic Knots were amazing, the pizza superb, and the three meals we tried were phenomenal e...
$$ $$
4.50 (320 reviews)
9
Gianni's Pizza & More
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Fuhgeddaboudit! Best pie I've had since being in Midtown Manhattan 2 years ago. Oh yeah and Real Garlic knots!!! The right size, cooked perfectly and dripping with the oil and garlic. If you're in Sarasota don't you dare leave without getting a slice!
$$ $$
4.40 (719 reviews)
10
Rico's Pizzeria & Pasta House
Southern Italian restaurant
Simple, long-time stalwart for New Jersey-style pies & Southern Italian comfort foods with beer.
$ $$$
4.30 (410 reviews)
11
Carmen's Italian Cafe
Italian restaurant
Easygoing, family-owned trattoria offering pastas, pizza & traditional mains, plus a martini bar.
$$ $$
4.00 (490 reviews)