Top rated Italian restaurants in Indianapolis

Experience the best that Indianapolis has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 42 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories



Sauce on the Side image
1
Sauce on the Side
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Sauce on the Side, aka, the Indianapolis restaurant which servers ONLY calzones! I recently had the courage to try this place out and here’s how it went. Pros: The calzone I had (The “Meat me in St. Louie”) was just out of this world. Everything was cooked to perfection and it had lots of flavor. I...
$$ $$
4.80 (414 reviews)
Mama Carolla's image
2
Mama Carolla's
Italian restaurant
Upscale Italian restaurant in a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa offering a full bar & a garden.
$$ $$
4.70 (2.2K reviews)
Nesso image
3
Nesso
Restaurant
Airy-industrial stop for Italian seafood, locally sourced meats & fresh pasta plus wine & cocktails.
$$ $$
4.70 (348 reviews)
Bluebeard image
4
Bluebeard
American restaurant
Trendy New American kitchen serving sharing plates & craft cocktails in a renovated 1924 warehouse.
$$$ $
4.60 (1.8K reviews)
Iozzo's Garden of Italy image
5
Iozzo's Garden of Italy
Italian restaurant
Storied eatery serves Italian classics & wine in its sophisticated dining room & quaint courtyard.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.6K reviews)
Brozinni Pizzeria image
6
Brozinni Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Family-friendly pizza place features the Big Apple's signature crust & a small menu of Italian eats.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.5K reviews)
Iaria's Italian Restaurant image
7
Iaria's Italian Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Open since 1933, this extra-homey, family-run institution dishes up classic pasta dinners & pizzas.
$$ $$
4.60 (1.4K reviews)
OP Italian image
8
OP Italian
Italian restaurant
JW Marriott restaurant serving Italian fare in a sleek space with a bar & glass-enclosed wine room.
$$$ $
4.60 (1.1K reviews)
Vito Provolone's image
9
Vito Provolone's
Italian restaurant
Relaxed, cozy Italian restaurant offering classic pastas & pizza, plus chicken & seafood dishes.
$$ $$
4.60 (952 reviews)
Xtrordinary Pizza image
10
Xtrordinary Pizza
Pizza restaurant
$ $$$
4.60 (943 reviews)
Ambrosia image
11
Ambrosia
Italian restaurant
Upmarket Italian cuisine served in a classy, contemporary restaurant with patio seating.
$$ $$
4.60 (574 reviews)
Sangiovese Ristorante image
12
Sangiovese Ristorante
Italian restaurant
Upscale, romantic Italian restaurant featuring a waterfront patio, a fireplace & jazz piano music.
$$ $$
4.60 (500 reviews)
Maialina Italian Kitchen + Bar image
13
Maialina Italian Kitchen + Bar
Italian restaurant
Traditional Italian cuisine is complemented by wine at this roomy, industrial-style haunt.
4.60 (367 reviews)
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza image
14
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Chain outlet offering build-your-own takeaway pizzas, to be cooked at home.
$ $$$
4.60 (173 reviews)
Maggiano's Little Italy image
15
Maggiano's Little Italy
Italian restaurant
Semi-upscale chain for classic Italian fare served family-style in a relaxed, polished space.
$$ $$
4.50 (3.2K reviews)
Bazbeaux image
16
Bazbeaux
Pizza restaurant
Creative thin- or thick-crust pies in a casual location with a patio, plus beer & wine.
$$ $$
4.50 (2.3K reviews)
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave. image
17
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave.
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The main area looks like any other college pizza by the slice place, but to the back left of the main restaurant is a hidden bar. GREAT bar with Excellent Bourbon and Whisky selection. You can bring your pizza and super long breadsticks to the bar and have a great time.
$ $$$
4.50 (2.1K reviews)
King Dough image
18
King Dough
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 My favorite pizza! I haven’t had one pizza disappoint! The crust is so yummy!! Great toppings and combinations! Just pick one that sounds good and it will be great! Those mozzarella cheese sticks are ridiculous too! Almost didn’t get a pic! They have hot honey and basil on them and that elevates the...
$$ $$
4.50 (1K reviews)
Giorgio's Pizza image
19
Giorgio's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Thin- & thick-crust pizza & subs from an Italian-born chef, plus beer & wine in a quick-serve space.
$ $$$
4.50 (950 reviews)
Capri Italian Restaurant image
20
Capri Italian Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Classy, long-running restaurant featuring Italian cuisine & wine plus a greenery-laden patio.
$$$ $
4.50 (878 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories


Last updated:
( )