Most reviewed Cookie shops in New York, United States to visit (Updated December, 2023)

Most reviewed Cookie shops in New York

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of New York through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 19 places from Cookie shop category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Schmackary's

Bakery

This bakery specializing in cookies offers 45+ different varieties, including gluten-free options.

$ $$$

4.50 (2.1K reviews)

Culture Espresso

Coffee shop

Tiny, art-adorned coffeehouse pairing its brews with baked goods, sandwiches & a local vibe.

$$ $$

4.60 (1.5K reviews)

Milk Bar

Dessert shop

Bakery for quirky, inventive desserts from lauded pastry chef Christina Tosi.

$$ $$

3.90 (1.1K reviews)

Circo's Pastry Shop

Bakery

Old-school family-owned Italian bakery offering pastries, cookies & custom special-occasion cakes.

$$ $$

4.60 (600 reviews)

Milk Bar

Dessert shop

Bakery for quirky, inventive desserts from lauded pastry chef Christina Tosi.

$$ $$

4.00 (558 reviews)

Milk Bar

Dessert shop

Bakery for quirky, inventive desserts from lauded pastry chef Christina Tosi.

$$ $$

3.90 (539 reviews)

Norma's Corner Shoppe

Coffee shop

Corner bakery & cafe serving locally roasted coffee, sandwiches & an array of cakes & pastries.

$ $$$

4.60 (536 reviews)

For Five Coffee Times Square

Coffee shop

Modern cafe for house-roasted specialty coffee, pastries, breakfast, and lunch plates.

$$ $$

4.20 (445 reviews)

Té Company

Tea store

Compact shop offering a selection of oolong teas, plus tastings & an intimate dinner experience.

4.80 (322 reviews)

Milk Bar

Dessert shop

Bakery for quirky, inventive desserts from lauded pastry chef Christina Tosi.

$$ $$

4.00 (287 reviews)

Vegan Grill

Vegan restaurant

Compact destination with an unpretentious vibe serving plant-based wraps, burgers & cookies.

$$ $$

4.60 (285 reviews)

Milk Bar

Dessert shop

Bakery for quirky, inventive desserts from lauded pastry chef Christina Tosi.

$$ $$

3.80 (257 reviews)

Sofia & Grace Cookie Company

Cookie shop

👍👍 The place is named after her daughters!! That’s so sweet!! I had the Jace with eggplant substituted for the jackfruit which was yummy and came with a side of chips. A homie neighborhood vibe. Good food and good company! Can’t wait to go back 🥰

$ $$$

4.60 (222 reviews)

Chip City

Cookie shop

👍👍 This was one of the most decadent cookies I have ever eaten. It was chewy like a brown yet crispy crunchy like a cookie. I would recommend you try it if you are in the area. We had chocolate chip and white chocolate cranberry macadamia nut... something like that... It was simply delicious

4.40 (95 reviews)

For Five Coffee

Coffee shop

Coffee shop at Brookfield Place serving drinks made with locally -roasted coffee beans & pastries.

$$ $$

3.60 (88 reviews)

Jamaica Halal Wings/Apnar Cha Ghar

Fast food restaurant

$ $$$

3.70 (81 reviews)

Marathon Coffee

Coffee shop

👍👍 A lovely coffee shop with inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. The shop offers a variety of baked pastries to pair with their selection of coffee. I ordered a cold brew with oat milk and caramel flavoring as well as a banana muffin which looked amazing. The coffee is bold with a nice tart flavor...

4.50 (65 reviews)

Mother Mousse

Bakery

😠 Working with mother Mother Mousse used to be a wonderful experience but new ownership changes have gutted this former neighborhood stalwart. My family and I had been consistent customers for years but we have recently found a precipitous drop in both the quality of their products and the attitude of...

$$$ $

4.00 (47 reviews)

Mrs. Fields

Bakery

Mall-based chain offering cookies, brownies & personalized cookie cakes.

$$$ $

3.70 (35 reviews)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Most reviewed Cookie shops in New York, United States