Most reviewed Italian restaurants in New York, United States to visit (Updated December, 2023)

Most reviewed Italian restaurants in New York

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of New York through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 757 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Carmine's

Italian restaurant

Relaxed, family-friendly restaurant serving a menu of homestyle Southern Italian meals.

$$ $$

4.50 (15.8K reviews)

L&B Spumoni Gardens

Italian restaurant

Sicilian square pizza & ice cream from an old-school Italian counter that opened in 1939.

$$ $$

4.60 (9.9K reviews)

Eataly NYC Flatiron

Market

Branch of the famed Italian market, offering counters, restaurants & cooking demos.

$$ $$

4.50 (8.9K reviews)

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

Casual, Brooklyn-based pizzeria chain serving brick-oven pies & calzones, plus wine & beer.

$$ $$

4.20 (8.4K reviews)

NY Pizza Suprema

Pizza restaurant

Established Madison Square Garden-area staple serving pizzas whole and by the slice.

$ $$$

4.60 (6.9K reviews)

Tony's Di Napoli

Italian restaurant

Bustling eatery serving large, shareable portions of Italian comfort food in a lively setting.

$$ $$

4.60 (6.4K reviews)

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads.

$$ $$

4.10 (6.3K reviews)

Ferrara Bakery & Cafe

Bakery

Venerable outfit offering its famed cannoli & other Italian desserts, plus espresso, since 1892.

$$ $$

4.40 (6.2K reviews)

OLIO E PIÙ

Italian restaurant

Naples meets NYC at this trattoria with thin-crust pizza, Italian wines & ample sidewalk seating.

$$ $$

4.60 (6.1K reviews)

Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Upper West Side

Italian restaurant

Relaxed, family-friendly restaurant serving a menu of homestyle Southern Italian meals.

$$ $$

4.40 (6.1K reviews)

Eataly NYC Downtown

Italian restaurant

Bread-themed branch of the famed Italian market, offering counters, restaurants, and cooking demos.

$$ $$

4.30 (5.4K reviews)

Bleecker Street Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Basic pizza shop on a busy corner that offers cheap slices & pies late into the night.

$ $$$

4.50 (4.7K reviews)

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads.

$$ $$

4.10 (4.4K reviews)

Rubirosa

Pizza restaurant

Casual spot serving reinvented Italian-American classics and thin-crust pizzas, including the standout Tie Dye pizza, in a cozy space.

$$ $$

4.60 (4.3K reviews)

Famous Original Ray's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Roomy outpost of a no-frills local chain serving slices & pies, calzones & other Italian eats.

$ $$$

3.90 (4.3K reviews)

Pine Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Longtime Italian eatery featuring a raw bar & classic entrees, including steak & seafood dishes.

$$ $$

4.50 (4.2K reviews)

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads.

$$ $$

4.00 (4.1K reviews)

Becco

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Fun time at Becco in NYC! We had an early reservation to make sure we got out in time for our evening musical and thankful we did so! We enjoyed the quickly delivered bread basket and olives along with our wine selections. Of course we had the serve-at-the-table pasta trio which was all you can e...

$$ $$

4.30 (3.9K reviews)

Little Italy Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Slices on-the-go, New York-style pies & calzones in a counter-service Midtown setting.

$ $$$

4.20 (3.7K reviews)

Da Gennaro

Italian restaurant

Traditional Italian eatery offering the standard red-sauce fare in an old-school setting.

$$ $$

4.20 (3.5K reviews)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Most reviewed Italian restaurants in New York, United States