Most reviewed Diamond dealers in New York, United States to visit (Updated December, 2023)

Most reviewed Diamond dealers in New York

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of New York through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 95 places from Diamond dealer category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

TraxNYC

Jeweler

Gold chains, watches & custom pendants feature at this retailer of jewelry & watches.

4.50 (2.1K reviews)

Rare Carat, Inc

Diamond dealer

👍👍 I wanted to upgrade my engagement diamond, after all it was over 30 years ago when I received my beautiful ring. I wanted a bigger and better quality diamond. After a lot of research, I decided to purchase a lab created diamond through Rare Carat. I was very pleased with the customer service and "Wo...

4.90 (2K reviews)

Lauren B Jewelry

Jewelry store

Open since 1978, this retailer specializes in engagement rings, custom designs & loose diamonds.

4.90 (1.5K reviews)

James Allen Showroom

Diamond dealer

😠 I've waited a long time to write this review because I was hoping James Allen would right their wrongs but so far this has not happened. In a nutshell this is what happened with my engagement ring. It's an engagement HORROR STORY! My husband purchased a ring from JA back in 2015, in 2020 I decided t...

4.50 (1.1K reviews)

With Clarity

Jewelry store

👍👍 Remi and Elton at With Clarity provide the best customer service. I love my ring! With Clarity has the best prices and the best rings! My Diamond solitaire setting is the cathedral basket other then loving the design and comfort of this ring what I also love about it is every band sits flush with it...

4.70 (1K reviews)

Cartier Fifth Avenue Mansion

Jewelry store

Luxury brand founded in 1847 specializing in high jewelry, jewelry, timepieces & accessories.

4.20 (832 reviews)

Frank Darling

Jewelry store

4.90 (733 reviews)

Casale Jewelers

Jewelry store

Long-running store offering a selection of jewelry & watches, plus jewelry repair services.

5.00 (707 reviews)

KAY Jewelers

Jewelry store

Retail jewelry chain featuring engagement rings, timepieces & designer collections.

$$$ $

4.70 (633 reviews)

Ultimate Diamond Co

Diamond dealer

👍👍 My fiancé and I walked in to Ultimate Diamond off the street in December 2021, and Billy was kind enough to help us, educate us, and assist us right then and there. I made a follow up appointment in the Spring of 2022 to see specific diamonds, and he again helped me design an amazing custom engageme...

4.80 (614 reviews)

Fascinating Diamonds

Jeweler

👍👍 Completely blown away at how beautiful the ring turned out. It was exactly what I was looking for and my fiancée absolutely loves it. At the time, I was definitely nervous for ordering something like this online and not being able to see it in person, but after chatting with Roger on the support cha...

4.90 (476 reviews)

Jangmi

Jewelry store

Longtime diamond specialist in the International Gem Tower known for its engagement & wedding rings.

4.80 (423 reviews)

ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches

Jewelry store

Men's & women's watches & jewelry, with custom pieces & loose gems, are on offer at this showroom.

4.70 (418 reviews)

Zales

Jewelry store

Chain retailer offering a wide variety of diamond & precious jewelry in classic & designer styles.

$$ $$

4.70 (397 reviews)

Abe Mor Diamonds

Diamond dealer

4.80 (385 reviews)

Diamond Source NYC

Watch store

👍👍 I finally found the perfect watch I wanted only to find out it was out of stock everywhere due to it being in low production. Lo and behold Diamond Source NYC! Carlos guaranteed me 1000% he can acquire the time piece. Being a careful online purchaser, I had my doubts. Especially since I am in Atlant...

5.00 (354 reviews)

Landsberg Jewelers

Jeweler

Showroom for designer diamond, gemstone & gold rings, earrings, necklaces & bracelets.

5.00 (326 reviews)

Gerald Peters

Jewelry store

Long-running store selling fine jewelry, from wedding bands to watches, in a contemporary setting.

4.90 (311 reviews)

Northeastern Jewelers & Estate Buyers

Jeweler

👍👍 At Northeastern Jewelers & Estate Buyers, Mike, Nick and Frank accomplished the seemingly impossible task for me. Their dedicated efforts in selecting the perfect ring for a stunning stone I brought in, with adjustments and restless work left me thoroughly impressed. Without a doubt, they have earne...

4.90 (286 reviews)

Kundan Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 My fiance purchased my engagement ring from Kundan Jewelers. They were able to make my dream engagement ring come to reality. Thank you Kundan Jewelers! The diamond was stunning and the ring was beautiful. The ring is sparkly and pictures do not do justice. If you're thinking about purchasing a dia...

4.90 (285 reviews)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Most reviewed Diamond dealers in New York, United States