Top rated Italian restaurants in Toms River, United States to elevate your visit (Updated March, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in Toms River

Experience the best that Toms River has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 39 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within Toms River

Breakin Bread Eatery

Italian restaurant

👍👍 This place is delicious! No if and or buts. The food is enormous the quality is tremendous and the price was fair. I don’t usually get chicken cutlet out because nothing can usually compete with my Italian mothers chicken cutlet but the OMG hot sub was the best I’ve had that didn’t come out of her k...

$$ $$

4.80 (152 reviews) (~5.92 km from centre)

Casertano's Cucina

Italian restaurant

👍👍 What a great place for catering! Ordered a sub tray and a wrap platter for my son's 3rd birthday party. Everything was fresh and delicious, my guests were raving about the bread used for the sandwiches. You get 24 pieces in each tray which was the perfect amount. Will be our go-to place for cateri...

$ $$$

4.80 (139 reviews) (~1.57 km from centre)

Fiore Rosso Restaurant & Catering

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Amazing meal great server michelle, went for Mothers day today 2021 and the food was on point 4 course meal and not rushed got to enjoy the meal

$$ $$

4.70 (200 reviews) (~7.73 km from centre)

Marie's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Love this place. Eating there since I was a baby. Best tuna salad ever!!

$ $$$

4.70 (63 reviews) (~1.83 km from centre)

Il Giardinello Di Bacoli

Italian restaurant

Casual Italian spot featuring traditional pasta entrees in an old-world, white-tablecloth space.

$$ $$

4.50 (950 reviews) (~3.67 km from centre)

Tardi's Ristorante Italiano

Italian restaurant

Simple yet homey BYOB with a large menu of traditional Italian entrees like veal Marsala.

4.50 (315 reviews) (~5.71 km from centre)

Italy's Best III

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Mmmm. This is the first pizza place I think of when I come back to NJ, one of the 2 states that actually knows how to make a real pizza pie!!!! SOOOO delicious all of the time; it's perfeeeecccctttttt. When you request it well done, you get it well done. Thank you 🙌 🤤😍

$$ $$

4.50 (224 reviews) (~1.91 km from centre)

Pondrelli's Pizza And Kitchen

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Best Pizza in Toms River!! No other pizzeria compares. Don't forget to say "Hi" to the brothers Luigi and Anthony.

$$ $$

4.50 (213 reviews) (~3.32 km from centre)

Artisan's Restaurant & Brewery

Restaurant

Warm, casual spot offering classic, homemade Italian & Mediterranean plates plus wine & craft beers.

$$ $$

4.40 (736 reviews) (~2.99 km from centre)

Villa Amalfi

Fine dining restaurant

Select Italian meat, fish & pasta dishes served in a relaxed space with Amalfi-themed murals.

$$ $$

4.40 (528 reviews) (~2.13 km from centre)

Johnny G's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Unpretentious sit-down Italian joint with classic pies, subs, pasta & entrees like veal piccata.

$$ $$

4.40 (365 reviews) (~7.6 km from centre)

Mia's Pizza Toms River NJ

Pizza delivery

😠 Wow. I am done trying to find a somewhat edible pizza in Toms River. Unless you want to eat it with a knife and spoon because everywhere I’ve tried they make it soupy just like this place! (Even when folded in half it still won’t stand up.) Just sad. I will show you what I received with pics. It was...

$ $$$

4.40 (319 reviews) (~4.34 km from centre)

Veraces Pizzas

Pizza restaurant

$$ $$

4.40 (90 reviews) (~7.73 km from centre)

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian standards such as pastas & salads.

$$ $$

4.30 (2.2K reviews) (~3.93 km from centre)

Charlie's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 Wow, what a disappointment. We don’t live in the area, but we pick up take out from time to time to bring when visiting my grandmother. Tried ordering online and tried to apply a coupon that I was emailed earlier this week. The website was buggy, told me the coupon couldn’t be applied, and to call...

$$ $$

4.30 (667 reviews) (~8.47 km from centre)

Enzo's Caffe Italia

Italian restaurant

Pizza, pasta & other Italian comfort food served in a traditional, down-to-earth dining room.

$$ $$

4.30 (497 reviews) (~5.72 km from centre)

Naples Pizza & Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

This family-owned joint serves pizzas, subs, pasta & other Italian basics in a relaxed atmosphere.

$$ $$

4.30 (395 reviews) (~6.12 km from centre)

Vito's Pizza & Pub

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 I heard of Rosato's from my friend who frequents this place. I totally get why she loves this place now. Food were good and service was great. Totally love the Scarpariello wings. The Veal Parmigiana is on point too.

$$ $$

4.30 (343 reviews) (~4.14 km from centre)

Linda's Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Just ordered for the first time ever, using the Slice app. My food was absolutely incredible. I ordered a Breaded chicken, fresh mozz and red roasted pepper sub, and also penne vodka. The chicken was fresh, juicy and thick. Every bite of my sandwich had everything in the sub. Taste was amazing. Pen...

$$ $$

4.30 (172 reviews) (~5.52 km from centre)

House of Pizza

Pizza restaurant

$ $$$

4.30 (106 reviews) (~5.43 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in Toms River, United States