looooooooved the seafood here, was amazing and so fresh after a hot day in key west. we got the grouper salad, the salmon salad, a shrimp basket with fries, and onion rings. the shrimp and onion rings were fried to perfection and deliciously crunchy, and the grouper and salmon salads were super light and fresh but definitely very filling. the outside seating was really chill too, definitely a cute place, and the customer service was excellent. super recommend ! :)

Great Food!!! My boyfriend and I ordered a 6 inch lobster roll, a 8 inch lobster roll and a bowl of cram chowder soup. They served fast and with lots of lobster inside rolls!! It was great 👍 Soup was not salty and little bit light tasted. I like that also. Foods are very delicious 😋 All staffs were welcoming and friendly. Outside seating areas are clean and spaces. Overall was great experience! I highly recommend this place!

Super helpful staff. Fun experience ordering fresh and having staff prepare for us. Had excellent fish tacos. Want more fish 🌮 😍. They were huge. And still want more. Freshest pink shrimp in town. The delicious peel and eat shrimp and stone crab are reason enough to bring us back. But when we come back we are trying the shrimp salad and the crabcakes.

Great seafood market that also serves cooked food. Stone crab claws, Key West pinks shrimp and royal reds shrimps!! They don't cook the royal reds for you, but if you are staying somewhere with a kitchen, buy these!! Highly recommend.

We had lunch here and was pretty decent! Lobster sandwich was decent but little over priced. Tuna sandwich was literally tasted like the canned but not sure. Shrimp Taco was pretty good 👍🏻 wish there were three instead of two 😋 Building itself is cute, neat, and unique restaurant. It has a good atmospheric view and mood👌🏻

Some of the freshest and best seafood, anywhere, served al fresco or to take with you. This is a great place to eat as much or as little as you want and enjoy every morsel or take it home and cook it yourself. There's no hard liquor but most anything else, with a good choice available. Highly recommended!

The food was pretty good, we ordered the lobster roll, crab cake sandwich, conch chowder, fish sandwich (ahi tuna), and some fresh shrimp. The crab cakes were very rich, it needed a little bit of lime to balance the richness. The fish sandwich was packed with tuna (my fish of choice) and the lobster rolls were also packed with lobster. The service was really good, the staff was really kind. Overall it was a good experience.

I have a new favorite spot in key west! The absolute best shrimp rolls, hands down. So fresh and tasty, it stays on the mind long after you finish. I had the conch fritters as well and they were beyond delicious. I returned the next day to make sure I tried the crabcake croissant and that didn't disappoint either. Tha patio outside was cool and clean which is a big plus considering the heat. Staff was friendly and service was very fast. It's a must the you stop here if you are in key west!!!

Eaton Street Seafood Market is a culinary gem in Key West. This restaurant is nothing short of spectacular, offering an array of mouthwatering delights, including amazing lobsters, delicious clam chowder, and much more. The lobsters at Eaton Street Seafood Market are truly outstanding. Cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor, they are a must-try for seafood enthusiasts. The clam chowder is equally delightful, offering a warm and comforting bowl of goodness. The restaurant itself provides a cozy and inviting ambiance, making it a perfect place to enjoy a memorable meal. The staff is attentive and friendly, ensuring an exceptional dining experience. If you're in Key West and looking for a restaurant with amazing seafood, including lobsters and clam chowder, Eaton Street Seafood Market is the perfect choice. It's a five-star destination that I can't recommend enough!

The scallops and lobster roll were delicious. We ordered 2 lobster tails, and they forgot them on the grill, so they were overcooked. I'm sure if they were cooked correctly, they would have been delicious as well.

One of the worst seafood experiences we've ever had. Total rip off, tourist trap, almost no conch in the ceviche. The chowder has pieces of sausage with basic tomato like sauce and vinegary with no proper chunks of conch. I strongly recommend avoiding the place, completely over-priced and terrible taste. No refund has been offered and the owner has been very aggressive to my wife in another review, which is completely unacceptable behaviour. The owner repeatedly says people "trashing business" in replies to negative reviews - you're not doing us a favor, we are giving you money for something, and you've not delivered. I'd be ashamed and embarrassed to serve this food to a customer. Please stop trashing your customers. Your emphasis on "business" highlights that all you care about is maximizing your money at the expense of the customer experience. Edit: Pathetic response from the owner. I purchased on credit card and have posted a picture of the transaction.

Best lobster roll in town 🙌 Lots of lobster meat. Nothing extra. Not much mayonnaise. Very, very fresh!!! ❤️

Pricy as advertised but also the food was as fresh as it gets. For 2 orders of shrimp tacos and a beer was about $50 bucks. With that being said, they tasted absolutely delicious. Whats very cool about this place too is that when you order your food, you are basically picking what you want from the raw cuts in the Market. Cool experience and worth a try.

As fresh as it gets. No frills just tasty food! As the other reviews said the lobster roll lived up to the hype! Crab cake sandwich also hit the spot. Setup is like a convenience store. Walk in check out all the fresh fish, caviar, drinks, etc. If you see something fresh in the case they can prepare it for you. There's also a menu hanging on the wall to order from. There are only 2 seats inside and the rest of the seating is outside. Once you place your order they will bring it outside to your table. Then it's time to dig in and enjoy. Everything you need is outside: napkins, condiments, ice cold water, etc. Plenty of shade and fans outside to keep you cool. Saved them in my favorite list because I'll be back.

Love this place. Great casual, outdoor seafood restaurant, perfect after spending the day at the beach. We had the delicious lobster roll which was made with the freshest chunks of lobster and just a hint of butter on the toasted bun. Heaven!

Excellent stone crab claws and lobster rolls and everything else. You just tell them how many claws you want. A bit expensive but very worth it as they’re a good size and already chilled and pre cracked. The lobster roll is enough for two people unless you’re a food gangster in which case it’s very filling. Small almost hole in the wall place but super clean and always friendly. Been going here for years. It’s a MUST DO EVERY TRIP! Seating is limited to just a few outdoor picnic tables but it’s well worth the wait for a table to become available. Try it and tell me I’m wrong!

I can't say enough about the freshness of their seafood! We ordered a shrimp salad roll and a crab cake sandwich! It was so good and we were going on a boat tour later, so we grabbed another shrimp salad roll for the trip and it held up so well! The plantain chips were great, too!

Order at the counter inside and the food is brought out to you. Nice outdoor seating area. We ordered a lobster roll, conch chowder, smoked fish dip, fish and chips. All very tasty, but the smoked fish dip was my favorite.

We are only in Key West a few days and we've already been here twice! We had fish tacos, shrimp tacos, a fish sandwich, and the conch strip basket and everything was so delicious! Even the coleslaw, fries, and plantain chips were good. Definitely one of our favorite places to eat on Key West.

Delicious food. Seat yourself. You order inside at the counter. We shared the spinach artichoke dip, conch chowder, and crab cake sandwich. Easy walking distance from Duvall St. Food was a tad on the salty side. Laid back outdoor seating. Neighborhood street parking.

We enjoyed our time at Eaton street! Both my mom and I had the crab cake sandwich and my dad had the fish sandwich . I asked for extra sauce on the side to dip my sandwich in and it was delicious! My dad also ordered the conch soup and was disappointed because it was basically tomatoes soup with a hint of conch. Keep in mind the photo of the seating area is basically the entire restaurant except for three bar stools inside where you order so if you are looking for an escape from the heat while you dine this may not work for you.

Worth stopping. I drove by the sign outside a few times advertising lobster rolls. Finally having a girlfriend "all-in" to stop for lunch, we were not disappointed. Take the time and enjoy how delicious their food is!

Great place, stopped for lunch and shared the Lobster Roll and had some visitors join us! We also took some seafood home with us, very good! Very pricey for the seafood though. Spiny Lobster was outrageous, seriously outrageous. So we took home the smoked fish dip excellent and Key West Pink Shrimp! Affordable and awesome. You shouldn't charge so much for the Spiny Lobster especially when it's Lobster season in the Keys!