Top rated Restaurants in Charlotte Amalie

Experience the best that Charlotte Amalie has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 45 places from Restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Momma's Shack image
1
Momma's Shack
Fast food restaurant
👍👍 Well well well, four days, twelve restaurants and finally ...the BEST food and drinks on the island. This is where the locals eat, folks. Business men and woman grabbing breakfast and lunch before work. Vegan options and real fruit juices. Ingredient number one, Ms. Carmen's well traveled skills...
4.90 (44 reviews)
Smoke Truck aka “Chickenman” image
2
Smoke Truck aka “Chickenman”
Barbecue restaurant
👍👍 Found this place via maps because it was in vicinity of my hotel. I got to the area and he had not arrived yet because of afternoon traffic. I stood around and had conversations with the locals while he parked and set up. There was a line as soon as he started! Glad i waited because it was definitel...
4.90 (43 reviews)
Karen's Place image
3
Karen's Place
Restaurant
👍👍 Karen is an amazing person, who knows how to make a delicious food! In our short vacation on the island 🏝 we became her regulars.
4.90 (40 reviews)
Blue Eleven image
4
Blue Eleven
Restaurant
👍👍 If you are in St Thomas this place is a MUST stop for their delicious tasting menu. Every course was amazing and the blend of flavors was like an explosion of taste to the palate. Be sure to make a reservation though as it is cozy and intimate. Our group of 8 sat at the bar to enjoy the 9 plate tast...
4.80 (296 reviews)
R2R Lounge image
5
R2R Lounge
Hookah bar
👍👍 I recently had an incredible experience at R2R Lounge in St. Thomas, Virgin Islands. The drinks were superb, offering a delightful range of flavors. The owner, not only beautiful but exceptionally kind, ensures a welcoming atmosphere. The enchanting vibe creates the perfect setting. The lounge's sec...
4.80 (139 reviews)
Sea La Vie image
6
Sea La Vie
Restaurant
😠 Dishonest and disgusting. We were recommended this place by our waiter at another restaurant, Amalia's, who told us this restaurant is authentic and not a tourist trap. He forgot to mention he also works at Sea La Vie, so it was quite a surprise when we showed up and saw he was our waiter again. W...
4.70 (146 reviews)
Ideal Restaurant image
7
Ideal Restaurant
Restaurant
👍👍 Try the hot roti, the veggie roti were potatoes and cauliflower is very flavorful and delicious! The roti are a thin tortilla and the sandwich are very filling!
4.70 (135 reviews)
Surf N' Turf Bistro image
8
Surf N' Turf Bistro
Restaurant
👍👍 Wow! Is my review in one word. In more detail, we were told about this restaurant from locals and it did not disappoint. We were served by one of the owners who answered all of our questions regarding the fresh seafood. I highly recommend this restaurant, especially if you have a party with vegan n...
4.70 (58 reviews)
Greengos Caribbean Cantina image
9
Greengos Caribbean Cantina
Mexican restaurant
👍👍 We were in Charlotte Amalie for 3 nights, but managed to stop here twice. The tequila selection is unreal - 350 tequilas currently available... Strong pours, good vibe, good alternative music, dog friendly 🐶
$$ $$
4.60 (850 reviews)
French Quarter Bistro image
10
French Quarter Bistro
Restaurant
👍👍 We dined at French Quarter Bistro during our vacation in St Thomas. To say the food was excellent is an understatement! We had the blackened red snapper, seasoned rice, and moax chow. We also had the pork chop which was huge and my wife said it was juicy and very seasoned. Our daughter had the shrim...
$$ $$
4.60 (804 reviews)
Stone House Cafe image
11
Stone House Cafe
Restaurant
👍👍 12/6/23— I stopped here for a quick cup of coffee . It is excellent . The two ladys working here love that they do . I can tell their hearts js in it and it’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas (song playing ) . You first pass the specialty coffee and the ice cream and a little more you will hit...
$$ $$
4.60 (382 reviews)
The Twisted Cork Cafe image
12
The Twisted Cork Cafe
Fine dining restaurant
Vibrant eatery serving eclectic comfort meals with Caribbean flair & global wines in a cozy setting.
$$ $$
4.60 (273 reviews)
MBW Cafe & Bakery image
13
MBW Cafe & Bakery
Restaurant
👍👍 The cutest bakery in charlotte amalie! We got to taste their coconut and vegan chocolate pastries straight from the oven! Their mission is awesome too. The back patio smells lovely since it’s right next to their kitchen. All the staff was so attentive and everything I bought from them was so yummy!...
4.60 (102 reviews)
Wingz Gone Wild & Carib Burgers image
14
Wingz Gone Wild & Carib Burgers
Restaurant
👍👍 The food and service here is really good! We tried boneless bbq wings, henny and honey wings, and the mango habanero wings as well. All three were great and so were their fries and drinks.
4.60 (92 reviews)
Mr Big Life Food Truck image
15
Mr Big Life Food Truck
Restaurant
👍👍 Great food, I totally recommend you to have the bbq chicken, his mac&cheese is also amazing. Thank you for your delicious food and your great service! We enjoyed it every day while in St. Thomas.
4.60 (32 reviews)
Gladys' Café image
16
Gladys' Café
Restaurant
👍👍 Our food was delicious!!! We went there because a Tim wanted conch fritters in the worst way. These didn’t disappoint. I even liked the conch soup! I ordered the grilled mahi with veggies and peas and rice. The fish was cooked perfectly and the veggies were delicious! The peas and rice were fr...
$$ $$
4.50 (1K reviews)
Virgilio's image
17
Virgilio's
Italian restaurant
😐 Absolutely loved the decor and ambiance of Virgilio’s. It took my family a couple of tries to finally get a reservation here, so our expectations were high. Expectations rose slightly once we saw the prices for each dish. There were many great options to choose from, especially for vegetarians, with...
4.50 (530 reviews)
Oceana Restaurant & Bistro image
18
Oceana Restaurant & Bistro
Seafood restaurant
👍👍 One of the best meals I've ever had. Perfect ambiance, perfect service, and the most excellent lobster, seabass and scallops that we've ever eaten. Just a perfect evening for our honeymoon dinner. Thank you to the staff and management for a delightful evening. Was it cheap? No. But it was so ve...
4.50 (509 reviews)
Amalia Café Restaurant image
19
Amalia Café Restaurant
Restaurant
Open-air eatery serving tapas & other classic Spanish fare plus wines in sunny, atmospheric digs.
4.50 (467 reviews)
Mi Casita Caribbean Food Dominican Restaurant image
20
Mi Casita Caribbean Food Dominican Restaurant
Dominican restaurant
👍👍 My favorite restaurant is St. Thomas!! The food was delicious and service was great! Everything was so good (specially the stew chicken and green bananas) honestly the best restaurant I had food from in the entire week we were in St. Thomas!! Completely recommend!! Thank you for the great food and s...
4.50 (250 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )