Hidden gems - Pizza restaurants in New York, United States not to miss (Updated December, 2023)

Hidden gems: Pizza restaurants in New York

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York. This list contains 22 places from Pizza restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Leonardo’s Pizza

Pizza delivery

$$ $$

5.00 (58 reviews)

Mama Mia's Pizza - Jamaica

Pizza restaurant

4.90 (12 reviews)

Traditas Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Found my go to pizza place in the financial district. Crust was excellent, one of the best I've ever had. And the sauce is great too. Very affordable pricing. Enough seats that unless you're there for a lunch rush you can probably sit.

$$ $$

4.80 (148 reviews)

Tutto Mia Pizza Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 What a great new neighborhood spot! I popped in here the other day with a friend because I saw this place just opened and have been wanting to try it. We ordered a few slices and salads to try out. The pizza was incredible. Perfectly cheesy with a delicious crust. No excess oil or sogginess. The sal...

$$ $$

4.80 (123 reviews)

Picciotto

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 Every single dish our large group tried was 5 stars. Including appetizers, pizzas, pastas, wines, gelatos, etc. Whatever you choose will be delicious and very authentic Sicilian. The atmosphere is excellent. Everyone is very friendly and caring. Everything is very clean and decorations are fun and a...

$$ $$

4.80 (108 reviews)

La Citta Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 This place was such an excellent find to stumble upon! We definitely didn’t expect it would be as good as it was given we were just looking to catch a quick bite late at night. The rainbow slice was full of so many flavors and I loved it! The staff were really friendly too.

4.80 (60 reviews)

Mama pizza and more

Pizza restaurant

😠 Stay away from this place!!! My family and I were really looking forward to enjoying some New York pizza. We ordered an 18” full pizza through the Slice app, when they showed up with only 3 slices of pizza I called and expressed my frustrations. They would not refund my money or send me more piz...

$ $$$

4.80 (22 reviews)

Verde's Pizza & Pasta House

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 One word... Freaking Amazing. Ok 2 words.. But man that meat lovers Pie an that Vodka Penne sauce is truly delish!! Nothing like it back home in Texas. Thank you for the recommendations. Will be back.

$$ $$

4.70 (148 reviews)

Carmine & Sons

Sports bar

Relaxed sports bar (est. 1979) for wood-fired pizza with varied toppings, with pints, wine & TVs.

4.70 (123 reviews)

Anas cafe

Restaurant

$ $$$

4.70 (102 reviews)

Alta Villa Cafe

Cafe

👍👍 This place is always fresh and delicious. My go to place for a home cooked meal. Healthy options too. They don't put butter or sauces on veggies, which I love. For around $10 you get a great meal.

4.70 (7 reviews)

Fratelli’s Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 The most delicious pizza I have ever tasted!

$ $$$

4.60 (131 reviews)

Bar Next Door at La Lanterna di Vittorio

Bar

La Lanterna di Vittori's next-door nook offers coffee, wine & light bites plus live jazz nightly.

$$ $$

4.60 (115 reviews)

Vaccaros Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 The worst place I’ve ever got pizza from. The customer service is the worst. I tried ordering over the phone and I’m asking my kids and my wife what did they want to order. The gentleman on the phone taking my order was rude because we didn’t decide fast enough on what pizza to order. He then pro...

$$ $$

4.50 (145 reviews)

Ottava

Italian restaurant

$$ $$

4.50 (123 reviews)

Brooklyn Beef N’ Cheese

Cheesesteak restaurant

$$ $$

4.50 (111 reviews)

Dongan Hills Pizza

Pizza restaurant

😠 Used to order every day. Spending money back to back. Ruined my order then tells me keep it will send you another. Then the delivery guy tells me give the food back I gave him back my garbage. Then they realized how much money I was spending in there and tried calling me back giving me more food....

4.50 (104 reviews)

Woodside Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant

$$ $$

4.50 (103 reviews)

Lake Como Pizza

Pizza restaurant

$ $$$

4.50 (60 reviews)

San Marino Oriental Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

🫤 Eddie made me amazing pepperoni pie, good size and perfect service. I went again tonight to deal with a rude person named raimo who messed up my order twice. I was told Eddie won’t be back. Very unfortunate.

$$ $$

4.50 (50 reviews)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Pizza restaurants in New York, United States