Hidden gems - Stores in New York, United States not to miss (Updated December, 2023)

Hidden gems: Stores in New York

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York. This list contains 18 places from Store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Justin the Jeweler (silver and gold Jewelry)

Jewelry designer

👍👍 Shop has many items to choose from. I was looking for something that I could wear everyday without taking it off. I have a heavy pendant so I purchased a 18 inch 14K white gold chain 3.2mm. I love it! It was exactly what I was looking for. I have been wearing it everyday & it is still shiny like new...

5.00 (64 reviews)

M.K. Sterling & Watches Inc.

Watch store

👍👍 Totally reputable, resourceful, old-school owner who's ready to help clients with whatever their jewelry needs are.

5.00 (9 reviews)

Standard Wormwood Distillery & Cocktail Bar

Distillery

👍👍 This bar is located within Industry City in Brooklyn, NY. The bar is extraordinarily beautiful with a great insustrisl atmosphere that has been mindfully preserved. The craft cocktails here are perhaps the best cocktails in the world. The names of the cocktails are very entertaining and the aroma an...

4.90 (48 reviews)

New King Jewelry

Jewelry store

4.90 (41 reviews)

Tendenza

Jewelry store

Creative designs, diamonds & hand engraving are the specialties at this quaint jewelry boutique.

4.90 (32 reviews)

Ergot Records

Record store

👍👍 What a fun new find! I hadn’t ever been here before and I’m delighted I stopped in. The bargain items outside the store caught my eye (I found two great classical records for a buck each) and then spent nearly two hours browsing and listening to their great selection of LPs. I found several really g...

4.80 (56 reviews)

Lucent Yoga

Yoga studio

👍👍 Cute local yoga spot, teachers vary so just try different classes until you find one you like. On ClassPass, has a great new student unlimited week deal. Mats are a little old/not cared for, so optimally you would bring your own.

4.80 (36 reviews)

Puffume

Store

👍👍 Amazing staff and amazing products 1000/10 honestly had such a great service. I recommend everyone to go there

4.80 (17 reviews)

Elite Sterling

Store

4.70 (25 reviews)

Oasis Coffee Shop

Coffee shop

👍👍 I ordered the Torta de chorrizo, Along with fries & mozzarella cheese on top. Very good! I work at 531 Tiffany st (CityPlus+) your neighbors down the street & I will definitely be ordering again soon.

$ $$$

4.60 (104 reviews)

Happy Sister Beauty Salon

Beauty salon

😠 These people do not listen. You tell them to cut 2 inches off and they cut 10 inches. You tell them it’s too short and they just laugh at you. I don’t even know why I tipped her. If I could give them 0 stars I would. She didn’t even ask if I liked it. Just chopped off all my hair and laughed in my f...

4.50 (113 reviews)

2430 Columbus Discount Inc

Store

👍👍 I sincerely believe they have Hoffa's body somewhere in the back. Anything, and I do mean ANYTHING you could ever need at good prices. Nice staff too. I have a vision problem and the guys are always glad to help. I wish I could list what they have in stock but I think Google limits you to 764 mi...

4.50 (49 reviews)

Relax Station INC

Massage spa

👍👍 Walked in on a whim 30 min before closing just to try our luck for a quick foot and calf massage for 2 people before heading back to the hotel. They welcomed us and worked out our very tired feet and legs from a busy week of walking around town. The massages felt sooo good, I tipped extra for their...

4.50 (45 reviews)

SCOSHA

Jewelry store

Colorful, quirky shop stocking women's & men's handcrafted jewelry plus home goods & more.

4.50 (33 reviews)

119 Aquarium

Store

👍👍 119 Aquarium is the best source for all your freshwater fish and invertebrate species. They have been a pillar of Chinatown for over 30 years. Support your local fish store! Support 119 Aquarium! Ask about their specialty tea imports as well.

4.50 (26 reviews)

enRoys Cafe

Cafe

😠 This was my first and last visit to this local business. I decided to give them a try and ordered a meatball sandwich, but ended up receiving the wrong order – a cheeseburger. To make matters worse, the burger was prepared in a very unappetizing way using a series of microwaves. When I asked the per...

$ $$$

4.50 (24 reviews)

Reinstein Ross

Jewelry store

High-end retailer of handmade & high-karat gold jewelry, from earrings to engagement rings.

4.50 (13 reviews)

Studio DuArte

Jewelry store

4.50 (10 reviews)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Stores in New York, United States