Hidden gems - Jewelry stores in New York, United States not to miss (Updated December, 2023)

Hidden gems: Jewelry stores in New York

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York. This list contains 313 places from Jewelry store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

VintageDiamondRing.com

Diamond dealer

5.00 (147 reviews)

Taylor & Hart

Jeweler

5.00 (146 reviews)

Tzfasman Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 I was so impressed with their service and kindness but most of all the woman that helped me was so patient answered all my questions, i really felt like i had all the time in the world and no pressure. I usually do not have this experience in this area of Brooklyn when i shop. Thank you so so much!...

5.00 (142 reviews)

TRINGA JEWELERS

Jewelry store

5.00 (139 reviews)

Vale Jewelry

Jeweler

Jewelry store selling modern pieces, including rings made with responsibly mined diamonds.

5.00 (138 reviews)

FANA

Jewelry store

5.00 (135 reviews)

Jewelry by Garo

Jewelry designer

👍👍 I looked around for a while to find someone who could produce a beautiful black diamond engagement ring. I found Garo and ended up ordering one through him. The ring is absolutely stunning, with a beautifully cut diamond. Garo promptly answered all of my questions, and was great to work with. We did...

5.00 (133 reviews)

Ascot Diamonds New York

Jewelry store

Boutique specializing in wedding jewelry with custom options, plus top-shelf statement pieces.

5.00 (120 reviews)

Ring Concierge

Jewelry store

5.00 (114 reviews)

Delicate Gem NYC

Jewelry store

Established, family-owned jewelry merchant offering high-quality diamond engagement & wedding rings.

5.00 (113 reviews)

Simon Ardem Diamond Jewelry

Jeweler

👍👍 Working with Simon Ardem for an engagement ring was such a pleasant experience. He is so professional, transparent, and understanding. Not only does he help educate his customers and explain each step of the process but he also gets the best stones for the best prices. He worked with my fiancé to cr...

5.00 (105 reviews)

Emerald Gem Exchange (DUMBO Showroom)

Jewelry store

👍👍 My partner, his mom, and I had the pleasure of visiting Siva while visiting NY—I could write a whole essay! He was very helpful and knowledgeable about his products. We stayed in there for a long time talking and learning about the stones we chose. He replaced the loop on my stone for a wire wrap an...

5.00 (99 reviews)

OSCARGAMA Jewelry Design Studio

Jewelry designer

👍👍 I am absolutely thrilled with my recent purchase from Oscargama Jewelry Design! Oscar’s engagement ring has exceeded all my fiancée’s expectations by capturing both the essence of love and elegance. From the moment I first enquired about the pieces I was interested in, Oscar always replied with war...

5.00 (99 reviews)

Ethan Jordan Jewelers

Jewelry store

👍👍 Isabella she’s good Servec to me , she very nice to me also thank Isabella happy Christmas to you!

5.00 (95 reviews)

The Natural Ruby Company

Jewelry manufacturer

👍👍 We worked with Lauren and she was amazing. First off, if you're shopping online for jewelry, my first concern is always safety and legitimacy. The Natural Ruby Company is totally legit!!! :) They have the best images of the stones that I've ever seen online, which made it really easy to pick the per...

5.00 (94 reviews)

L&L Jewelry Unit #12

Jewelry designer

👍👍 L & L Jewelry is awesome!! 1st time customer from So Calif. I did my online research, found a beautiful Heart Charm Paper Link Bracelet in 14K Rose Gold for my wife as a Christmas gift. I ordered it online. My purchase was confirmed quickly. The next day Abraham confirmed my delivery date with me. I...

5.00 (90 reviews)

Glitz & Glam $5 Jewels LLC

Jewelry store

5.00 (87 reviews)

ALFASE JEWELRY

Jewelry store

👍👍 Amazing new place with unique pieces of jewelry. Prices are reasonable, some of them are so good you won’t believe it.

5.00 (84 reviews)

Mio Watches and Jewelry

Watch store

👍👍 Purchased a Rolex 31mm lady’s Datejust for my niece. Mio Jewelers was recommended by a family member. Their staff is and was absolutely stunning in helping me to find a watch on super short notice. Will def buy more pieces! Prices are incredible.

5.00 (72 reviews)

Fantastic jewelry nyc online Jewelry store real gold 100%

Jewelry store

👍👍 Great service and definitely best prices around. Wayne is the true definition of excellent customer service

5.00 (66 reviews)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Jewelry stores in New York, United States