Hidden gems - Apartment rental agencies in New York, United States not to miss (Updated December, 2023)

Hidden gems: Apartment rental agencies in New York

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York. This list contains 33 places from Apartment rental agency category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Heritage Apartments @ 115 East 37th Street

Furnished apartment building

5.00 (84 reviews)

Heritage Apartments @ 111 East 39th Street

Furnished apartment building

👍👍 The living experience in 3RL of 138 E37 St, NY was very good, the house is big and comfortable. Eko, the janitor, was very helpful and solved all my problems in time. The housekeeping aunt cleans the rooms very well every month. There were never any strange people in the building and it was very saf...

5.00 (33 reviews)

Real Key NYC

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 I just want to say thank u to Mr.kenny ,the landlord and the super and the entire Real Key I'm so overwhelmed and Happy and Honored that ya"ll gave me this hope this blessing for me and my two sons my our very own first apartment thank u all so much I must say u work fast and you get the job done t...

5.00 (9 reviews)

Upper East Side Apartments

Apartment rental agency

5.00 (8 reviews)

470 Manhattan

Apartment building

👍👍 Beautiful popsicle and champagne event hosted by the wonderful Taisha!

4.90 (93 reviews)

800 Sixth

Apartment rental agency

😐 Sept-2023 EDIT: After 2 years (me) and 7 years (my girlfriend) living in this building, I unfortunately have to lower the rating from 5 stars to 3. While the doormen are still great and the building itself has good amenities, there are 2 main factors that have changed. First, the location has degra...

4.90 (84 reviews)

568 Union

Apartment building

👍👍 This review is about the amazing staff here. The building is great too, but the people that work here are what makes this a great place to walk into. I can’t praise them enough! Liz, Joseph, Jeneera, Tiffany, Niko, Bennie and everyone else here are so welcoming and friendly. Keep it up fam!

4.90 (74 reviews)

544 Union

Apartment building

👍👍 We have been living at 544 Union since the building opened, over 6 years ago. Originally, we rented a one bedroom and upon starting a family, we upgraded to a two bedroom. Our experience living here has exceed our expectations. The building's maintenance staff is amazing, the concierge service is th...

4.90 (48 reviews)

1214 Fifth Avenue Luxury Apartments

Apartment complex

👍👍 It has good facilities and it's excellent overall

4.80 (13 reviews)

461 Dean Apartments

Apartment rental agency

👍 Lived here for a year, but had to move out due to costs. Amazing views with great amenities. Building staff was nice. Be aware it was very easy to get locked out of your apartment and it cost some money for them to come unlock you space. Location is unbeatable since you are next to almost all Brook...

4.70 (53 reviews)

The Westport Luxury Apartments

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 I had the best experience living at the building for a bit more than 4 years! Management is great, staff are super friendly, and the dogs in the building are the best! Even tho I moved out during the pandemic, but I can't wait to be back especially my current building has nothing to compare with the...

4.70 (38 reviews)

New York Plaza

Apartment building

👍👍 Super clean, quiet and great spot for food any time of the day. Security is on top of things and makes sure the place is kept clean and safe.

4.70 (22 reviews)

The Tate

Apartment rental agency

4.70 (22 reviews)

1871 House

Short term apartment rental agency

Antiques-filled suites, some with fireplaces, in a historic townhouse offering a/c & private baths.

4.70 (20 reviews)

One Carnegie Hill

Apartment complex

👍👍 This Related building is a fantastic place to live in the Upper East Side. It is conveniently located 1.5 blocks from the 6 train and will be half a block from the new 2nd Ave subway when it opens. The doormen and staff are excellent and all amenities are exactly as promised. Plus, all apartments ha...

4.70 (17 reviews)

393 West End Avenue

Apartment building

👍 Good

4.70 (14 reviews)

456 Washington St. Luxury Apartments

Apartment building

👍👍 Fantastic views, comfortable and convenient location. Safe neighborhood. Luxury at it’s finest!

4.70 (10 reviews)

261 Hudson Apartments

Apartment complex

4.70 (7 reviews)

The Ashland

Apartment rental agency

😐 I've lived here for a few months now and everyone I've interacted with in the building is wonderful and really goes above and beyond to make you feel welcome. I can't express my appreciation enough for them. That said, the situation with 1-3 elevators continuously having problems is awful. It's not...

4.60 (74 reviews)

101 West End Avenue Luxury Apartments

Apartment complex

😠 Not a great price/ value you can see they tried to update but the vinyl floor is already coming from underneath and make pay extra to use other amenities in the building. Besides that one of the elevators were broken 90% of the time we were there. Maintenance and Management unfortunatley had a lot...

4.60 (61 reviews)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Hidden gems: Apartment rental agencies in New York, United States