I have been ordering pizza, subs and chicken tenders from here for the last 3 years. I have tried delivery from 20 plus other restaurants and nowhere else comes close. Plus they have a great reward system when you order direct. I lived in nyc for many years and this place is the closest to the classic cheese pizza Does not deserve this average low rating!

The food is amazing, massive slices of pizza for only 4.50. We got our pizza in less than 5 minutes with a full restaurant. We sat down and ate at a booth and the atmosphere was great. We came in around noon and there were multiple local construction workers getting lunch so I knew this place is good and cheap.

Service was quick and pizza was excellent. The slices are big and offer good bang for your buck (~$5 per slice depending on toppings). I’ve been a few times over the past year and the pizza and service has been consistent. Would recommend.

My go to place for oozy gooey yummy pizza. The slices are huge and have a great price to quantity ratio. The onion rings and the fried chicken (freshly made in front of you) have the perfect amount of crunch and seasoning. The subs are also a good option if ure very hungry. But the winner is definitely the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza!!!! The crust is thin yet crunchy, the cheese is stretchy, and the toppings generous.

The pizza was good for a quick meal

Incredibly rude service staff. Do not ask them any questions about their menu because they will act like you ran over their pet dog. Mediocre food that is overpriced. Check out any of the other local pizza places instead.

I paid $20+ on just a small pizza and it never got delivered or refunded. From out of town and certainly won't trust them with my business again.

Have been ordering here for years, and we love these guys!! The BLT with swiss cheese is one of the best subs in Boston.

Great pizza. Huge slices. Great deal of 2 slices and 1 drink for around $11. Went back a second time as the pizza was that good

Supreme Pizza and Subs has an exceptional New York style slice of pizza. I visited on my trip to Boston and found both the staff and the food to be an upgrade from the traditional hole in the wall pizzeria. The slices were greater than two hands wide, leaving you feeling satisfied. The price shocked me when the total for two was less than a $10 spot.

The slices are really big not your average size and the buffalo pizza was the best I ever had. The area is a busy area but we found parking.

Don't understand why this place doesn't have better ratings but the pizza here is legit. It's 3$ by the slice and its consistently thin and crispy with a perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. I did order delivery once though and that pie was disappointing. It arrived in time but the pizza itself didn't even resemble the ones from take out, stale crust and tasteless sauce. Wouldn't do that again but if you're craving a NY slice, I'd really recommend this place for in-store

Rude staff,like really rude. Ordered a take away pizza and they gave me the wrong pizza. But have no problem changing me for the pizza I order. So NOT New York style pizza!!!!

50/50 with this place sometimes it’s great other times it’s soggy and gross. Didn’t even eat this, took one bite, threw it out and got DoorDash. They just need to be more consistent.

Ordered for the first and last time. I understand how the fast food business can be stressful but the guy at the counter is by far the rudest person I’ve ever met! Truly A1 a-hole!

Bumped into this place after a concert and it was just what the doctor ordered. Slices are huge and delicious. The folks working there moved through the line surgically. Perfect late night stop and we will return!

one of the best pizza slices i’ve ever had, very generous with cheese and the crust tastes amazing. Service is excellent and quick, easy food to grab after a late night out. Would definitely recommend!