Top rated Italian restaurants in St. Catharines, Canada to elevate your visit (Updated February, 2024)

Top rated Italian restaurants in St. Catharines

Experience the best that St. Catharines has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 98 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within St. Catharines

Casa Contadina

Italian restaurant

👍👍 This place is AMAZING, as an Italian I felt like home in Niagara falls. The food is spectacular, the people are amazing, everything's perfect. Btw, don't listen to the 2 stars comment (the guy/girl is Mahsa M.), clearly that's the type of person that would give 5 stars to a McDonald's, and call it...

4.90 (96 reviews) (~14.95 km from centre)

Pasquale's Trattoria

Italian restaurant

Casual eatery with modern decor serving pasta, pizza & other Italian dishes, with lunch specials.

$$$ $

4.80 (515 reviews) (~46.85 km from centre)

Frattello's

Italian restaurant

👍👍 this sandwich shop is AWESOME! bring cash cuz you need to tip big! fresh ingredients ✔️ hella kewl location ✔️ righteous owner ✔️ grabbing lunch and felt like i was in a current filming for "A Bronx tale". can't fake this awesome. this is what the world needs more of: great food made by hard...

4.80 (140 reviews) (~17.13 km from centre)

Mele Trattoria

Restaurant

👍👍 My mom and I went here for dinner, unexpectedly, as we are from out of town and will definitely make our way into St. Catharines just for dinner here again. Everything was so delicious and the service was great. Congrats to the Chef :)

$$ $$

4.80 (120 reviews) (~0.34 km from centre)

Cafe Amalia

Italian restaurant

👍👍 If you hear a person talking about not enjoying the atmosphere, they simply do not understand where they are. It is attached to their home and the fantastic couple are proud to serve you. The drinks and gelato are great, plus you can ask if they have any food (the sandwiches are great). All this for...

$ $$$

4.80 (111 reviews) (~17.4 km from centre)

Valley

Italian restaurant

👍👍 When seated, you’re started off with a complimentary focaccia bread drizzled in balsamic and olive oil. We ordered the fried provolone to start which was delicious. I definitely recommend the house lasagne as the portion is large, it tastes absolutely fantastic and for $20 you will not find somethin...

$$ $$

4.70 (810 reviews) (~7.19 km from centre)

Just Cooking Rustic Italian

Italian restaurant

$$ $$

4.70 (808 reviews) (~12.34 km from centre)

San Marco's Ristorante

Italian restaurant

Dine-in · Kerbside pickup · Delivery

$$ $$

4.70 (302 reviews) (~30.26 km from centre)

Stoney's Bread Company

Restaurant

Bright, open space serving sandwiches on house-baked bread, plus pizza & homemade pasta.

$$ $$

4.60 (1.9K reviews) (~47.55 km from centre)

Coppola's Ristorante & Banquet Facility

Italian restaurant

Familiar Italian fare, including pasta dishes & family-style meals, served in casual surrounds.

$$ $$

4.60 (1.4K reviews) (~1.78 km from centre)

The Boot Social Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Neapolitan-style pizza is the focus at this contemporary parlor also serving Italian tapas & vino.

$$ $$

4.60 (808 reviews) (~48.31 km from centre)

Di Mario’s Trattoria

Italian restaurant

Homestyle Italian cuisine & wines of Italy, served in a rustic environment with old-world decor.

$$$ $

4.60 (508 reviews) (~48.48 km from centre)

Matteo's

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Matt Is a true master in his element. His restaurant is a true expression of his gift. His food is his gift. My family had the pleasure of enjoying one of our favorite meals of all time at his restaurant just last Saturday. We enjoyed many items from the menu including linguine, gnocchi, deconstruct...

$$ $$

4.60 (498 reviews) (~18.43 km from centre)

Paesano Pizza

Pizza takeaway

👍👍 Ordered panzerotti from the Carlton location and amazing. We were driving back from Niagara Falls and wanted panzerotti. We didn't know how big they would be so we ordered 2 small and 1 large. OMG! Delicious. Will def6order from here again.

$ $$$

4.60 (475 reviews) (~4.43 km from centre)

Giuseppe's Italian Cuisine & Pizza

Italian restaurant

Stalwart outpost serving traditional Italian dishes in a white-tablecloth setting.

$$ $$

4.60 (321 reviews) (~49.77 km from centre)

Gigi's Pizza House

Pizza restaurant

$ $$$

4.60 (106 reviews) (~18.98 km from centre)

Mabel's Gourmet Pizza

Pizza restaurant

👍👍 A Crystal Beach staple! Delicious pizza, beautiful building with indoor seating and an outdoor patio. We’ve tried the pepperoni pizza and Buffalo wing pizza and both were delicious. Thin crust NYC style.

4.60 (74 reviews) (~35.77 km from centre)

Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Burlington

Italian restaurant

👍👍 Really one of the best locations when it comes to service and food quality. Always my favorite Italian restaurant. Belgian moon beer 🍺, fried calamari, pene polo and fettuccine shrimp.

$$ $$

4.50 (1.7K reviews) (~49.59 km from centre)

The Barrel Restaurant

Italian restaurant

Homey eatery offering classic Italian & American comfort foods plus souvlaki, fried fare & full bar.

$$ $$

4.50 (1.5K reviews) (~38.34 km from centre)

Napoli Ristorante Pizzeria

Italian restaurant

Long-time eatery offering Neapolitan-style pizza, pasta & Italian entrees in a relaxed setting.

$$ $$

4.50 (1.4K reviews) (~14.97 km from centre)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Italian restaurants in St. Catharines, Canada