#1
Most reviewed Italian restaurants in Toronto
Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Toronto through these extensively reviewed and popular spots.
All
Food & Drinks
Entertainment
Things to do
Shopping
Wellness
Accommodation
Religion
Tours
Activities
Sort by
Filters Advanced · Supporters
#2
Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Sherway
Italian restaurant
Travel destination with mixed reviews.
4.50
(7K reviews)
#3
#4
Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Dixon Rd
Italian restaurant
A italian restaurant in Toronto, Canada with strong reviews and consistent service quality.
4.80
(5.6K reviews)
#5
Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Don Mills
Italian restaurant
Modern establishment with strong reviews and consistent quality.
4.80
(4.9K reviews)
#6
La Vecchia Restaurant Lakeshore
Italian restaurant
A well-regarded establishment with solid reviews.
4.50
(3.4K reviews)
#7
Mamma Martino’s Restaurant
Italian restaurant
A popular destination offering diverse experiences and attractions for travelers.
4.30
(3.2K reviews)
#8
East Side Mario's
Restaurant
Destination with positive reviews and visitor feedback.
4.10
(3.1K reviews)
#10
Italian bakery/cafe with a case of cookies, pastries & gelati, plus deli meals & a sit-down space.
4.50
(2.9K reviews)
#11
La Vecchia Restaurant Uptown
Italian restaurant
Bustling Italian eatery for traditional cuisine, with black-&-white photos & decor evoking the past.
4.40
(2.8K reviews)
$$
$$
#12
Eden Trattoria
Italian restaurant
Relaxed Italian place with outdoor seats & an airy interior serving pasta, pizza & weekend brunch.
4.40
(2.7K reviews)
#13
California Sandwiches
Sandwich shop
Part of a local chain, this cash-only eatery specializes in substantial Italian sandwiches.
4.20
(2.7K reviews)
#14
Remezzo Italian Bistro
Italian restaurant
Casual eatery with Impressionist art & warm wood tones, serving Italian staples plus ribs & steaks.
4.20
(2.6K reviews)
#15
#16
Paisano's Original Italian Garden Cafe
Italian restaurant
A sleek contemporary dining room known for its selection of classic Italian cooking.
4.20
(1.8K reviews)
#17
Pizzeria Libretto
Pizza restaurant
Wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas made with simple ingredients & served in a bustling space.
4.40
(1.8K reviews)
#18
850 Degrees Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
Small, arty spot featuring an array of wood-fired pizzas made from locally sourced ingredients.
4.60
(1.7K reviews)
#19
Speducci Mercatto
Italian restaurant
Busy Italian restaurant & gourmet deli/butcher serving traditional fare in a convivial atmosphere.
4.70
(1.7K reviews)
#20
IL FORNELLO on Danforth
Italian restaurant
Pasta & Neapolitan-style pizza in a bright, modern setting that has a spacious patio.
4.30
(1.6K reviews)
#21
Milestones
Restaurant
Contemporary chain known for their Bellinis, featuring twists on typical bar & grill offerings.
4.00
(1.6K reviews)
#22
Via Allegro Ristorante
Italian restaurant
A 5,000-bottle wine cellar is a highlight at this upscale spot for modern Italian-Continental fare.
4.50
(1.6K reviews)
#23
Gio Rana's Really Really Nice
Italian restaurant
A big nose hangs outside this bustling eatery with small plates of housemade Italian comfort food.
4.70
(1.4K reviews)
#24
FiAMMA Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Italian dining in a chic space, with an open-air courtyard, wine bar & weekend live music.
4.40
(1.4K reviews)
$$$
$
#26
Parcheggio
Italian restaurant
Italian race cars inspired the decor of this restaurant serving house-made pasta & other favourites.
4.00
(1.3K reviews)
#27
il Paesano Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Relaxed Italian eatery serving classic pies, sandwiches & homemade pasta, with delivery available.
4.40
(1.3K reviews)
#29
Fratelli Village Pizzeria
Italian restaurant
Pasta & wood-fired pizzas in an inviting setting with exposed brick & warm wood tones.
4.60
(1.1K reviews)
#30
Mezza Notte Trattoria
Italian restaurant
Italian classics like pizza & housemade gnocchi, plus traditional music & an extensive wine list.
4.20
(1.1K reviews)
#31
Pizzeria Oro Di Napoli
Italian restaurant
Neapolitan-style pizza & other Italian comfort fare offered in a laid-back, warm atmosphere.
4.40
(1.1K reviews)
#32
Sorento Italian Kitchen
Italian restaurant
Mediterranean & Italian entrees, including wood-fired pizza, served in open & colourful environs.
4.30
(1.1K reviews)
#33
IL FORNELLO - Bayview Village
Pizza restaurant
Mall outpost of a local Italian restaurant chain, serving pasta & thin-crust pizzas.
4.20
(1.1K reviews)
#34
#35
#36
Rocco's Plum Tomato - The Original
Italian restaurant
Cheery & rustic Italian outfit with a back patio offers traditional cuisine & fire-cooked pizza.
4.40
(1K reviews)
#37
Popular Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Bustling, simple pizza place whipping up pies with a wide variety of toppings & dipping sauces.
3.60
(1K reviews)
#38
#39
Dino's Wood Burning Pizza
Pizza restaurant
This simple counter-service spot with patio serves thin-crust pizzas, Turkish pides, wings & salads.
4.40
(937 reviews)
#40
SIP Wine Bar Restaurant & Authentic Neapolitan Pizza
Italian restaurant
Wine, gourmet pizza & traditional Italian fare offered in a relaxed, sophisticated setting.
4.30
(891 reviews)
#41
ViBo Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Stained glass & a fireplace set the tone for seasonally inspired Italian fare & a 200+ label cellar.
4.50
(813 reviews)
$$$
$
#42
Danforth Pizza House
Pizza restaurant
Long-standing, no-frills hub with an old-world vibe, serving up classic pizza in simple digs.
4.50
(762 reviews)
#43
La Veranda Osteria
Italian restaurant
Spacious Italian spot with a casual vibe, offering a huge menu, wine cellar & lush patio.
4.20
(753 reviews)
#44
Baretto Caffe
Coffee shop
This modern, minimalist Italian spot serves espresso, pasta, pizza, panini & pastries.
4.80
(747 reviews)
#45
Pizzeria Via Napoli
Italian restaurant
Pasta, wood-fired pizza & other Italian staples, plus cocktails, in a casual haunt with a patio.
4.50
(745 reviews)
#46
Panino Cappuccino
Italian restaurant
Hideaway eatery with a cozy bistro vibe & a menu of Italian comfort food & house-baked focaccia.
4.60
(745 reviews)
#47
Pulcinella (Toronto) Ristorante & Wine Bar (established 2010)
Italian restaurant
Classy choice, serving traditional Italian cuisine & a lengthy wine list, plus Neapolitan pies.
4.50
(738 reviews)
$$
$$
#48
Grappa Restaurant
Italian restaurant
Storied family-run spot for Northern Italian fare & housemade desserts, plus grappa & wine lists.
4.70
(728 reviews)
#49
7 Numbers DANFORTH
Southern Italian restaurant
Menus change nightly in this cozy space with wine bottle candelabras & Italian family-style dining.
4.30
(716 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps
Filters
Categories
PageCrawl.io
Free for 6 pages
Get an email when a page changes.
Price drops, restocks, competitor pricing, policy changes — personal or business.
Claude · ChatGPT · Cursor
Plan a trip to Toronto with your AI assistant
Connect top-rated.online to Claude, ChatGPT or any MCP-compatible assistant and ask:
“Plan 3 days in Toronto — top sights, food and a walkable route.”
Connect your AI assistant →Cities near Toronto
- Markham (~11 km)
- Pickering (~15 km)
- Old Toronto (~17 km)
- Richmond Hill (~19 km)
- Ajax (~21 km)
- Vaughan (~22 km)
- Whitchurch-Stouffville (~22 km)
- Whitby (~28 km)
- Aurora (~30 km)
- Oshawa (~35 km)
- Newmarket (~35 km)
- Mississauga (~37 km)
- King (~38 km)
- Uxbridge (~39 km)
- Bolton (~40 km)
- East Gwillimbury (~41 km)
Italian restaurants in nearby cities
Last updated: