Hidden gems: Hotels in New York City

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York City. This list contains 19 places from Hotel category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Nine Orchard image
1
Nine Orchard
Hotel
Polished hotel offering chic rooms & suites in a converted 1912 bank, plus dining & a cocktail bar.
4.90 (80 reviews) (~4.05 km from centre)
Sonder City Hall Park image
2
Sonder City Hall Park
Hotel
👍👍 We cannot recommend Sonder enough. The rooms are way more spacious compared to Hilton or Marriott, and cheaper if you are staying longer. The kitchen is well appointed, with all the utensils you need. The bathroom is good sized, water pressure is great. The fantastic features include free washers an...
4.80 (147 reviews) (~5.06 km from centre)
Pendry Manhattan West image
3
Pendry Manhattan West
Hotel
Elegant rooms & suites in a posh hotel offering a gym, a stylish restaurant & bars, plus breakfast.
4.80 (133 reviews) (~1.59 km from centre)
The Modernist Hotel image
4
The Modernist Hotel
Hotel
4.70 (105 reviews) (~3.81 km from centre)
Mount Morris House NYC image
5
Mount Morris House NYC
Bed & breakfast
19th-century brownstone with fireplaces, parquet floors & some antique furnishings, plus free Wi-Fi.
4.70 (58 reviews) (~6.69 km from centre)
The Fifth Avenue Hotel image
6
The Fifth Avenue Hotel
Hotel
4.70 (53 reviews) (~0.86 km from centre)
Hotel Des Artistes image
7
Hotel Des Artistes
Apartment building
👍 Very famous in past decades. But now more stylish.
4.70 (18 reviews) (~2.62 km from centre)
Jefferson bnb image
8
Jefferson bnb
Bed & breakfast
👍👍 My stay here has been so amazing. The host is very professional, and will diligently exceed your expectations. Don't get me started on how the place is always kept so clean. I'd give it 6 stars!
4.70 (11 reviews) (~8.33 km from centre)
Bristol Plaza image
9
Bristol Plaza
Hotel
Luxury extended-stay suites with free Wi-Fi, plus a health club & an indoor pool.
4.60 (73 reviews) (~2.18 km from centre)
RH Guesthouse image
10
RH Guesthouse
Hotel
Elegant accommodations in a high-end hotel offering a chic dining room & a rooftop infinity pool.
4.60 (59 reviews) (~2.56 km from centre)
Inn At Irving Place image
11
Inn At Irving Place
Hotel
Victorian-inspired rooms in twin 1834 brownstones, offering dining, cocktails & luxe tea service.
4.60 (50 reviews) (~1.67 km from centre)
Upper Yorkville Suites image
12
Upper Yorkville Suites
Hotel
Contemporary studios & apartments with full kitchens and exposed brick walls, plus free WiFi.
4.60 (20 reviews) (~5.3 km from centre)
Hotel Hilton Financial image
13
Hotel Hilton Financial
Hotel
Warm quarters, some with city or river views, in a refined high-rise hotel offering dining & a gym.
4.60 (9 reviews) (~5.46 km from centre)
Guerlain Spa at The Plaza image
14
Guerlain Spa at The Plaza
Spa
🫤 I received a gift card for Signature massage for my bday and was very excited to try this place out. However, my experience was extremely disappointing for the price you pay and I will never come back or recommend this place to anyone. Guerlain Spa is located inside The Plaza but besides that, ther...
4.50 (119 reviews) (~1.67 km from centre)
The Broome Hotel New York image
15
The Broome Hotel New York
Hotel
Fashionable hotel offering free continental breakfast with locally sourced food & drinks.
4.50 (109 reviews) (~3.59 km from centre)
Hotel Fouquet's New York image
16
Hotel Fouquet's New York
Hotel
Chic rooms & suites in a choice, French-style hotel with a spa, a brasserie & a bar, plus a cinema.
4.50 (96 reviews) (~3.86 km from centre)
Harlem Loft image
17
Harlem Loft
Hotel
👍👍 I stayed here over the weekend, visiting from Florida with my sister. We had a little issue with our window not closing and the property manager immediately assisted us and made our stay even better. With code security, we felt extremely safe. If you are visiting New York, stay here instead of Times...
4.50 (26 reviews) (~7.31 km from centre)
255 West Guesthouse image
18
255 West Guesthouse
Hotel
Casual guesthouse offering 4 warm rooms with smart TVs, plus a lounge with a piano.
4.50 (26 reviews) (~7.68 km from centre)
Arlington Place image
19
Arlington Place
Hotel
Upmarket guesthouse in an 1880s property offering polished rooms, plus a rooftop garden & a lounge.
4.50 (11 reviews) (~8.01 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near New York City

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )