Hidden gems: Pastry shops in New York City

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York City. This list contains 18 places from Pastry shop category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Halaweyat Hala image
1
Halaweyat Hala
Pastry shop
👍👍 I had two custom cakes made for my sister and mothers birthday from Halaweyat Hala. I stumbled upon their page as they’re the only bakery I found who makes the knafeh into shapes (like the letter ‘C’ I got for my sister). We’re actually Greek, but my sister LOVES knafeh. The knafeh was absolutely de...
4.90 (114 reviews) (~8.35 km from centre)
Beanmonger Coffee image
2
Beanmonger Coffee
Coffee shop
👍👍 Beanmonger Coffee shop stands out as a haven of cool vibes and exceptional brews. From the moment you step inside, you'll be captivated by its inviting atmosphere, the skillfully crafted Partners coffee as well as other beverages. Def cant forget about the tasty treats that seem to change often an...
4.90 (104 reviews) (~8.07 km from centre)
KITE Coffee & Gelato image
3
KITE Coffee & Gelato
Coffee shop
👍👍 Kite is definitely one of the dopest Coffee, Gelato & Recreational establishments I’ve been to. Pretty decent Gelato & some of the best thc products for the best prices in the City! I’ve been using their product for the last 6 months with no complaints or plans to take my business elsewhere. Definit...
4.90 (32 reviews) (~3.39 km from centre)
Caffe Maria image
4
Caffe Maria
Coffee shop
👍👍 Nov 23’ Back again today and again impressed with the service, warm atmosphere, and quality food and coffee. This place is a rare gem in this part of town! Oct 23’ Good pizza. Great atmosphere. Looking forward to hearing the live music some time and the owner’s karaoke ;-j
$ $$$
4.80 (93 reviews) (~5.09 km from centre)
OS Cafe image
5
OS Cafe
Coffee shop
😐 I had a thoroughly average experience here on a Saturday morning. The one employee working appeared extremely frazzled, doing the work of at least two people. The texture of the almond croissant I ordered was not right at all- very chewy on the ends to the extent that it sort of hurt my mouth to che...
4.80 (81 reviews) (~9.49 km from centre)
Kafe Nio image
6
Kafe Nio
Cafeteria
👍👍 Kafenio has truly become my go-to spot for an exceptional dining experience in New Jersey. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that set the tone for a fantastic meal. The menu at Kafenio is a delightful journey through Mediterranean flavors that never fai...
$ $$$
4.80 (30 reviews) (~6.3 km from centre)
Mary's Bakery image
7
Mary's Bakery
Pastry shop
👍👍 If you're looking for authentic South American treats and sweets this is the place to go. Definitely worth it!
4.80 (12 reviews) (~5.07 km from centre)
Miss Bagel image
8
Miss Bagel
Bagel shop
👍👍 Instant neighborhood gem. If you live in bedstuy you already know we have been hurting for a decent bagel place. This place is the brekkie (and lunch!) answer to our deli-desperate prayers. 🙏🏾 Bagels are excellent: classic soft chewy inside and a perfectly crispy (somewhat crunchy in the best way)...
$$ $$
4.70 (112 reviews) (~8.1 km from centre)
Claire's Kitchen Cafe image
9
Claire's Kitchen Cafe
Cafe
👍 Great place for a nice chill breakfast with a friend. Was a bit more than flies I'd like buzzing around and the tables need to be cleaned a little better, but overall, nice atmosphere.
$$ $$
4.70 (84 reviews) (~6 km from centre)
tikal cafe image
10
tikal cafe
Coffee shop
Laid-back outfit serving meat-free breakfast sandwiches, salad bowls & burgers, plus cocktails.
$ $$$
4.60 (135 reviews) (~9.12 km from centre)
Blank Street Coffee image
11
Blank Street Coffee
Coffee shop
👍👍 Found this little coffee shop and honestly a great coffee, service was top notch. Will be visiting again for a coffee hit. Just slightly loud with the music. (Even though it was good). Almond Croissant was aiggght. Needs more inner-filling. But passable.
4.60 (96 reviews) (~1.2 km from centre)
Blank Street Coffee image
12
Blank Street Coffee
Coffee shop
Snug cafe chain outlet with a hip feel serving java, lattes & baked goods like cookies & croissants.
$ $$$
4.60 (78 reviews) (~2.8 km from centre)
Blank Street Coffee image
13
Blank Street Coffee
Coffee shop
$ $$$
4.60 (66 reviews) (~1.95 km from centre)
Three Jewels Cafe image
14
Three Jewels Cafe
Coffee shop
👍👍 Lovely place! Has wifi and clean bathroom. There are a few seats but the place is comfy and cozy and quiet. I spent great time talking with a friend, and the tea was great.
4.60 (52 reviews) (~2.79 km from centre)
Blank Street Coffee image
15
Blank Street Coffee
Coffee shop
😐 It was raining the day I went, and they have an open pet policy. I love dogs but in such a tiny store, the place can easily smell like dog sweat! Which was the case when I was there. So I really couldn't enjoy my coffee at all. Quite overrated. I'd give it less than 2 stars if the staff wasn't so fr...
$ $$$
4.60 (19 reviews) (~4.25 km from centre)
Champers Social Club image
16
Champers Social Club
Bar
👍👍 I stopped by on a Friday evening to have a drink (Pomegranate and Lime Spritz) and read for a bit. Even at 5-6pm, it was calm and on the empty side. The bartender was very knowledgeable about champagne and up for giving recommendations and chatting. Prices are standard for Soho. I didn't have any fo...
4.50 (109 reviews) (~3.54 km from centre)
Manhattan Espresso Cafe image
17
Manhattan Espresso Cafe
Coffee shop
This tiny coffee shop serving specialty drinks along with baked goods, sandwiches & housemade soup.
$ $$$
4.50 (78 reviews) (~0.89 km from centre)
Blank Street Coffee image
18
Blank Street Coffee
Coffee shop
$ $$$
4.50 (52 reviews) (~2.72 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near New York City

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )