Hidden gems: Pizza restaurants in New York City

Discover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York City. This list contains 24 places from Pizza restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
 Most reviewed  
🤩
 Hidden gems  
💎
 Worst rated  
🤬
 Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius

Categories


Leonardo’s Pizza image
1
Leonardo’s Pizza
Pizza delivery
$$ $$
5.00 (58 reviews) (~5.45 km from centre)
Fabiano’s Pizza image
2
Fabiano’s Pizza
Pizza delivery
$$ $$
5.00 (12 reviews) (~4.45 km from centre)
Gardenia image
3
Gardenia
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Can’t be much nicer than to give a cup of coffee when I don’t have any cash. Will be back real soon!!!
5.00 (5 reviews) (~7.79 km from centre)
Urban Tomato image
4
Urban Tomato
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This is the absolute best pizza I've ever had. I got half Buffalo chicken and half Fungi and let tell you it HIT THE SPOT. It was my wife's and I first anniversary and this place made it very special. They also were generous enough to give us an excellent Sunday on a chocolate chip cookie as a deser...
$$ $$
4.90 (124 reviews) (~6.71 km from centre)
Traditas Pizza image
5
Traditas Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Found my go to pizza place in the financial district. Crust was excellent, one of the best I've ever had. And the sauce is great too. Very affordable pricing. Enough seats that unless you're there for a lunch rush you can probably sit.
$$ $$
4.80 (148 reviews) (~5.26 km from centre)
Tutto Mia Pizza Restaurant image
6
Tutto Mia Pizza Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 What a great new neighborhood spot! I popped in here the other day with a friend because I saw this place just opened and have been wanting to try it. We ordered a few slices and salads to try out. The pizza was incredible. Perfectly cheesy with a delicious crust. No excess oil or sogginess. The sal...
$$ $$
4.80 (123 reviews) (~1.33 km from centre)
Pizza Amore image
7
Pizza Amore
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 You simply CANNOT get a better pizza! I have yet to eat a pizza that makes me as happy and the entrees are also amazing! The staff is incredibly friendly and my only fear is that once I leave this review, the line will be down the block and I won’t be able to get in lol. Bravo Amore Pizza! You will...
$$ $$
4.80 (64 reviews) (~8.71 km from centre)
La Citta Pizzeria image
8
La Citta Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This place was such an excellent find to stumble upon! We definitely didn’t expect it would be as good as it was given we were just looking to catch a quick bite late at night. The rainbow slice was full of so many flavors and I loved it! The staff were really friendly too.
4.80 (60 reviews) (~1.79 km from centre)
Mama pizza and more image
9
Mama pizza and more
Pizza restaurant
😠 Stay away from this place!!! My family and I were really looking forward to enjoying some New York pizza. We ordered an 18” full pizza through the Slice app, when they showed up with only 3 slices of pizza I called and expressed my frustrations. They would not refund my money or send me more piz...
$ $$$
4.80 (22 reviews) (~1.68 km from centre)
Burana Pizzeria Cubana image
10
Burana Pizzeria Cubana
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Cuban-style Pizza and Speghetti - Little Cuba in New Jersey I was curious on why there was no official Little Cuba in NYC. After my trip to Miami 2 weekends ago, I was looking for fresh Cuban food and, to my surprise, I found out that right across the water in Bergen, NJ, there was a massive Cuban...
$ $$$
4.70 (129 reviews) (~4.82 km from centre)
Carmine & Sons image
11
Carmine & Sons
Sports bar
Relaxed sports bar (est. 1979) for wood-fired pizza with varied toppings, with pints, wine & TVs.
4.70 (123 reviews) (~4.93 km from centre)
Anas cafe image
12
Anas cafe
Restaurant
$ $$$
4.70 (102 reviews) (~0.42 km from centre)
Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet - New Jersey image
13
Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet - New Jersey
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Super excited that we have a restaurant of the caliber of Enzo Bruni in our neighborhood! Let’s support it so Enzo Bruni can become a staple of our neighborhood and continues to grow! Quality ingredients, great execution of the dishes which took us back straight to the streets of il Mare vicino a Ro...
$$ $$
4.70 (75 reviews) (~4.44 km from centre)
Anthony GM Pizzeria image
14
Anthony GM Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This is our top home-delivery option these days because of the great taste and quick delivery... and let me tell you something about this place, the delivery guy was really funny at the time that we opened the door, he said something like: "are you ready for deliciousness!?" He was right, the pizza...
$ $$$
4.60 (141 reviews) (~8.86 km from centre)
West New York Pizza image
15
West New York Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 The pizza is so fresh and delicious. I love Hawaiian pizza and Garlic knots!! I also order pasta and cake, everything is yummy. Pizza dough is amazing. They just open the restaurant but highly recommend you guys to try! Friendly servers and good price 👍👍👍 Also the restaurant is so clean and ver...
$ $$$
4.60 (126 reviews) (~4.5 km from centre)
Bar Next Door at La Lanterna di Vittorio image
16
Bar Next Door at La Lanterna di Vittorio
Bar
La Lanterna di Vittori's next-door nook offers coffee, wine & light bites plus live jazz nightly.
$$ $$
4.60 (115 reviews) (~2.73 km from centre)
Overdose Café image
17
Overdose Café
Coffee shop
👍👍 I ordered the shrimp thin crust pizza and it was so good. I dove right in and forgot to take a picture of the full thing, but this is part of it :-) I can’t wait to try other flavors. What I love about it is that they offer very unique takes to your traditional toppings, which I very much appreciate...
$$ $$
4.60 (87 reviews) (~4.83 km from centre)
Chicos Pizza and Restaurant image
18
Chicos Pizza and Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Best pizza in town hands down. Crust, sauce, cheese, everything so delicious. Highly recommend!!
$ $$$
4.60 (22 reviews) (~8.09 km from centre)
Pizza Bite image
19
Pizza Bite
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 This is one of the best vegan pizzas I’ve ever had!! I know my food (I’m from New Orleans) and just moved from California where vegan options are bountiful, so I know what a good vegan pizza should taste like. I ordered the Melanzane pizza with vegan cheese instead and for delivery since I’m in a...
$$ $$
4.50 (134 reviews) (~8.55 km from centre)
Ottava image
20
Ottava
Italian restaurant
$$ $$
4.50 (123 reviews) (~9.56 km from centre)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories

Cities near New York City

View all places in United States

Last updated:
( )