Top rated Apartment rental agencies in New York, United States to elevate your visit (Updated December, 2023)

Top rated Apartment rental agencies in New York

Experience the best that New York has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 77 places from Apartment rental agency category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Heritage Apartments @ 115 East 37th Street

Furnished apartment building

5.00 (84 reviews)

Heritage Apartments @ 111 East 39th Street

Furnished apartment building

👍👍 The living experience in 3RL of 138 E37 St, NY was very good, the house is big and comfortable. Eko, the janitor, was very helpful and solved all my problems in time. The housekeeping aunt cleans the rooms very well every month. There were never any strange people in the building and it was very saf...

5.00 (33 reviews)

Waterline Square Rentals

Apartment rental agency

4.90 (285 reviews)

AVA High Line

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 I have moved into the Ava High line building from the Flat Iron district and happy with the decision. The building and the units are new and have new appliances with in-unit washer/dryers which is a huge plus! The gym has professional machines, weights, and equipment and isn't the usually apartmen...

4.90 (244 reviews)

Avalon West Chelsea

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 I moved into this building in March and I LOVE living here! Wonderful views of the water and sunset from my apartment. Walking to work takes me past art galleries that are constantly putting up new exhibits. Easy access to the high-line. Dog park & basketball court only 4 quick blocks away. My AC...

4.90 (236 reviews)

Avalon Bowery Place

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 The Avalon Bowery is an excellent choice for Manhattan living. The building and its staff work hard to ensure a luxurious experience daily. Andy, the doorman, is the epitome of strong hospitality. He brightens the days of the tenants and gets to know everyone's names. The rest of the doorman crew is...

4.90 (172 reviews)

470 Manhattan

Apartment building

👍👍 Beautiful popsicle and champagne event hosted by the wonderful Taisha!

4.90 (93 reviews)

800 Sixth

Apartment rental agency

😐 Sept-2023 EDIT: After 2 years (me) and 7 years (my girlfriend) living in this building, I unfortunately have to lower the rating from 5 stars to 3. While the doormen are still great and the building itself has good amenities, there are 2 main factors that have changed. First, the location has degra...

4.90 (84 reviews)

568 Union

Apartment building

👍👍 This review is about the amazing staff here. The building is great too, but the people that work here are what makes this a great place to walk into. I can’t praise them enough! Liz, Joseph, Jeneera, Tiffany, Niko, Bennie and everyone else here are so welcoming and friendly. Keep it up fam!

4.90 (74 reviews)

544 Union

Apartment building

👍👍 We have been living at 544 Union since the building opened, over 6 years ago. Originally, we rented a one bedroom and upon starting a family, we upgraded to a two bedroom. Our experience living here has exceed our expectations. The building's maintenance staff is amazing, the concierge service is th...

4.90 (48 reviews)

AVA Fort Greene

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 The concierge is great - Michael, Kenyon (especially), Rafael, Gladys, Arturo, and maintenance team are all attentive to the tenants needs and are very helpful. From time to time the elevators don't work properly (generally just one of the three). Besides that Avalon offers spectacular views, great...

4.80 (1.1K reviews)

Rentopia

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 Daniel Y has made the NYC apartment hunting process so easy and we're so thankful he helped us find our apartment. He was incredibly kind and always quick to respond. 10/10

4.80 (658 reviews)

AVA DoBro

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 I’m writing this review to express my gratitude to Orlando.G for his exceptional service in fixing the air conditioning unit in my apartment. Orlando responded promptly to my maintenance request and showed remarkable professionalism throughout the repair process. He not only fixed the issue efficien...

4.80 (373 reviews)

Avalon Morningside Park

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 I moved to Avalon Morningside Park In May '23. My experience with the staff at the building before I moved in, and since, has been amazing. From the beginning, the staff in the management office (Camden and Michael) was extremely helpful, professional, and gracious. Whatever comes up they respond q...

4.80 (181 reviews)

Avalon Clinton

Apartment rental agency

4.70 (357 reviews)

Avalon Willoughby Square

Apartment rental agency

4.70 (285 reviews)

Insurent Lease Guaranty: Rental Cosigner Service

Insurance agency

👍👍 THE BEST COMPANY EVER! Charles and Jeffrey are some of the best people you can find. They were so accommodating, and willing to help me in anyway that they could. They were extremely responsive, and walked me through every step. We were approved and guaranteed in less than 24 hours. Please do yourse...

4.70 (253 reviews)

461 Dean Apartments

Apartment rental agency

👍 Lived here for a year, but had to move out due to costs. Amazing views with great amenities. Building staff was nice. Be aware it was very easy to get locked out of your apartment and it cost some money for them to come unlock you space. Location is unbeatable since you are next to almost all Brook...

4.70 (53 reviews)

The Westport Luxury Apartments

Apartment rental agency

👍👍 I had the best experience living at the building for a bit more than 4 years! Management is great, staff are super friendly, and the dogs in the building are the best! Even tho I moved out during the pandemic, but I can't wait to be back especially my current building has nothing to compare with the...

4.70 (38 reviews)

The Howell

Apartment building

😐 Carlton is the best concierge you could ever have. He is detail-oriented, helpful, and friendly. While there are certain issues with the management team at the Howell (slow in responding to emails, never take the calls, take weeks and speaking with the upper managers to respond to complaints etc.) I...

4.60 (311 reviews)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Apartment rental agencies in New York, United States