Top rated Pet supply stores in New York, United States to elevate your visit (Updated December, 2023)

Top rated Pet supply stores in New York

Experience the best that New York has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 29 places from Pet supply store category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

Wespaw Pets

Pet supply store

👍👍 Very glad this place is in the neighborhood! I must admit I do buy the majority of my pet supplies online in bulk for convenience, but I always come here if I want to try new products, run out of stuff or want a specific recommendation from an actual human being. Their prices are extremely comparabl...

4.70 (191 reviews)

pupculture

Dog day care center

😠 TERRIBLE experience and service ... my dog is completely unrecognizable! Just moved to the neighborhood and left a wonderful groomer that is a little too far to use, so I decided to try this place for a dog groom. Had the absolute WORST experience – the groomer ignored my request and photo I showed...

4.70 (173 reviews)

Best Aquarium Service NYC, Inc.

Aquarium shop

😠 This man Felix is a fraud. His company/website is fraudulent. When we initially found his service online, he was in constant communication for our initial tank cleaning. He claimed that he does not take check, only cash! As a business we need to keep a record of all our expenses, therefore I explai...

4.70 (83 reviews)

Nature's Reef & Reptile

Pet store

👍👍 Came here nearly a year ago now for my first Crested Gecko...staff was extremely helpful, and very patient with me. To me, the prices were fair. Educated me on how to take care of my new gecko, and a year later, she's honestly great. Super sweet temperament, and doing well. I'm looking to get anothe...

4.60 (223 reviews)

Pet Ark Harlem

Pet supply store

👍👍 The staff are really helpful and friendly. George is really knowledgeable and gives good recommendations on products to try as one of my cats was really picky and needed special food. He can answer any questions you may have. Highly recommend.

4.50 (190 reviews)

Pet Central 76th Street

Pet store

👍👍 Staff, headed by the delightful Foni, is friendly and helpful. The store is usually well-stocked, even in the pandemic. Moreover, if they ever are short of something, they go the extra mile to locate it at another Pet Central location. Delivery service is always reliable: they show up when they s...

$$ $$

4.50 (67 reviews)

Court Street Pet Food

Pet supply store

👍👍 It goes to show how ignorant some people are. Mildred Roth you are absolutely not a customer and people can obviously see that through your ignorant false comment. Your just a bored sad old lady . By the looks of your profile there isn’t a store that reaches your expectations apparently . Stop lyin...

4.50 (33 reviews)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.40 (3.3K reviews)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.40 (1.5K reviews)

Brooklyn Zoo & Aquarium Pet Store

Pet store

Spacious shop offering puppies, kittens, fish, birds, exotics & supplies, plus grooming & boarding.

4.40 (591 reviews)

Greenland Pet Supplies/Grooming

Pet supply store

😠 Experience with Nora was simply awful today. She quoted me 120$ for grooming a yorkie and when I came to pick him up the price jumped to 180$ for all the add ons I haven’t agreed to. She even threatened to call the police and started making up things like your dog was matted and I need to charge mor...

4.40 (56 reviews)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

4.30 (1.9K reviews)

PetSmart

Pet supply store

Chain featuring a range of pets, supplies & food (most offer grooming, boarding & other services).

$$ $$

4.30 (1.5K reviews)

PetSmart

Pet supply store

Chain featuring a range of pets, supplies & food (most offer grooming, boarding & other services).

4.30 (1.2K reviews)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.30 (1K reviews)

Whole Pets Market

Pet store

😠 This store was pet land before and for some odd reason the manager was very pleasant. After this chain took over every time I come here I have an extremely negative experience. The manager has become rude and dismissive which in turn the rest of the staff is as well. My husband got yelled at like a...

$$ $$

4.30 (483 reviews)

LITTLE CREATURES

Pet store

👍👍 My dog Reza is THE Maniacal Monster of the Upper West Side. We stop into Little Creatures every day because Reza literally pulls me into this store because he loves Jill and the rest of the crew so much. They have all witnessed my dogs growth and development. This store is where we buy treats, Ch...

4.30 (62 reviews)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.20 (2.3K reviews)

Petco

Pet store

Chain with pet food & supplies such as toys, beds & pet technology products, plus medication.

$$ $$

4.20 (928 reviews)

New Lucky Fish Aquarium & Pet Supply

Pet store

👍👍 Oof! I would say it's a great place to get fish and accessories for ur aquarium, I've been going here for a while now and there's no other place I would go but here! I would recommend for anyone to check it out! And for the people that say " its horrible and y'all fish be dying " bruh I bet half of...

4.20 (243 reviews)

« Previous page
Next page »

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Pet supply stores in New York, United States