Top rated Catholic churches in New York, United States to elevate your visit (Updated December, 2023)

Top rated Catholic churches in New York

Experience the best that New York has to offer with our curated list of top-rated places. Sorted by average review scores from venues boasting over 30 reviews, these establishments promise exceptional quality and experiences to elevate your visit in the city. This list contains 16 places from Catholic church category.

Sort results by

Best

Top rated

Most reviewed

Hidden gems

Worst rated

Recently discovered

🆕

Search radius

1 km 2 km 5 km 10 km 30 km 50 km 100 km 250 km

Within New York

St. George Ukrainian Catholic Church

Catholic church

👍 Some have said on here, that it was the same old thing every year.. and maybe thinking they would not attend. I would like to remind people, that if you are coming to church expecting something new.. possible you are attending for the wrong reasons. It is not about the church, or the same old servic...

4.90 (287 reviews)

St. Malachy Roman Catholic Church - The Actors' Chapel

Catholic church

This longtime Catholic church doubles as a venue for actors to rehearse & perform original plays.

4.90 (270 reviews)

St. Mary Star of the Sea

Catholic church

👍👍 One of the most down to earth churches I have been too. Mass was about 35min or less.

4.90 (35 reviews)

St. Patrick's Cathedral

Cathedral

Towering Neo-Gothic church from 1879 with twin spires & storied history opposite Rockefeller Center.

4.80 (36K reviews)

St. Paul the Apostle Church

Catholic church

👍👍 This Roman Catholic Church could have the subtitle of art museum- a stunning location that honors God the Father and houses His son Jesus. A stunning building close to Fordham Univeristy graduate school buildings run by The Paulist priests. It was easy to feel at home here - even as a visitor. Mak...

4.80 (637 reviews)

Shrine and Parish Church of The Holy Innocents

Catholic church

👍👍 We didn't know that this beautiful and traditional Catholic Church existed in the midst of the busy city. Walked in to a Latin mass, just solemn. Confession and exposition of Blessed Sacrament were present. It was really hot inside the church, but it isn't about being comfortable while Christ is giv...

4.80 (452 reviews)

St Peter's Roman Catholic Church

Catholic church

👍👍 A beautiful Roman Catholic Church around the corner from One World Trade. Visited on a weekday at noon to find the celebration of a mass about to start. Beautiful service.

4.80 (384 reviews)

Church of St. Ignatius Loyola

Catholic church

Late 19th-century church with a highly decorative, vaulted nave & venue for choral & organ concerts.

4.80 (331 reviews)

Our Lady of Pompeii Church

Catholic church

👍👍 Exploring churches in Manhattan is a hobby of mine. Whenever I have time, I like to scout out churches that I've never been to and visit. I happened to be in the neighborhood after having had lunch near by and found this church. The exterior of the church is a more sedate, Greek revival style wit...

4.80 (227 reviews)

The Basilica of St. Patrick's Old Cathedral

Catholic church

Catholic cathedral & landmark built in early 19th century, formerly seat of Archdiocese of New York.

4.70 (1.3K reviews)

Church of St. Joseph of the Holy Family

Catholic church

👍👍 This is one of the most dramatic and dynamic parishes I've ever celebrated Mass with. If you look them up on YouTube, in particular there choir, you will find an enormously diverse range of offerings. And the dramatic depth of their music is very much a reflection of the variety and depth of the par...

4.70 (426 reviews)

Most Precious Blood Roman Catholic Church

Catholic church

😠 Bad church. We went here on Ash Wednesday. It was right after thev3:00PM service, 3:35 to be exact. I asked if we could receive ashes he said "No!" When I told him we came from Jackson Heights (and it was raining) he said " they have churches in Jackson Heights!" What a terrible response. My Mom is...

4.70 (240 reviews)

Holy Trinity Roman Catholic Church

Catholic church

😠 I walked 15 blocks to go for their advertied free breakfast. I got their at 8:30 am. There was a group of homeless men eating. I'm a hiker going to Maine and didn't look like I was from a different cohort. They said we're out of soup, all we have is a sandwich. Oh, and water if it's like. Those poor...

4.70 (129 reviews)

Church of Our Lady of Esperanza

Catholic church

😠 Some of the older Lady's that worship here are not nice at all, in the winter my car got stuck in the snow in front of the church and saw one older lady with the shovel went in the church entrance to ask her please let me use the shovel to dig my car out, the younger lady with her said yes and the...

4.70 (60 reviews)

Holy Cross Roman Catholic Church

Catholic church

👍👍 This was the church and the school at the time of my youth 1st and 2nd grade, I was not fortunate to be here to attend 3rd to the 8th at Holy Cross but I believe this was the school I was to be seated from start to finish. I see a vision of a beautiful graduation. I had many friends and classmate...

4.60 (148 reviews)

St. Nicholas of Tolentine Catholic Church

Catholic church

😠 Bad service. Called at 9:20 today to ask if our company could donate toys and 200 chicken dinners and the young lady said we don’t have kids and they don’t need it. We stated ok but can we speak with the Pastor. She HUNG UP. People are hungry and thats this churches approach. 👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾👎...

4.50 (95 reviews)

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

Top rated Catholic churches in New York, United States