Most reviewed Italian restaurants in Atlantic City

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Atlantic City through these extensively reviewed and popular spots. This list contains 30 places from Italian restaurant category.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Atlantic City image
1
Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Atlantic City
Italian restaurant
Relaxed, family-friendly restaurant serving a menu of homestyle Southern Italian meals.
$$$ $
4.40 (3.2K reviews)
Angelo's Fairmount Tavern image
2
Angelo's Fairmount Tavern
Italian restaurant
Old-school Italian eatery established in 1935 offering generous servings of classics & a wine list.
$$ $$
4.50 (2.2K reviews)
Tony's Baltimore Grill image
3
Tony's Baltimore Grill
Bar & grill
Trendy, late-night pizzeria dishes up classic pies & Italian comfort eats in an old-school interior.
$ $$$
4.20 (2K reviews)
Chef Vola's image
4
Chef Vola's
Italian restaurant
Longtime BYOB hideaway supplying traditional, homestyle Italian fare in charming surrounds.
$$$ $
4.70 (1.4K reviews)
Tony Boloney's Atlantic City image
5
Tony Boloney's Atlantic City
Pizza restaurant
Hip, buzzing spot for creatively named pizzas, subs & other snacks, with inventive topping options.
$$ $$
4.10 (1.2K reviews)
Gino's Pizza image
6
Gino's Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Casual, high-ceilinged pizza parlor serving specialty pies, sandwiches, burgers & wings until late.
$$ $$
3.90 (973 reviews)
Pizza Di Roma image
7
Pizza Di Roma
Pizza restaurant
No-nonsense counter-serve joint for pies & Italian subs, plus burgers, gyros & other basic bites.
$ $$$
3.60 (956 reviews)
Cafe 2825 image
8
Cafe 2825
Italian restaurant
Classy eatery featuring from-scratch Italian cuisine, a full bar & ample wines in an intimate space.
$$ $$
4.60 (755 reviews)
Popa Pizza image
9
Popa Pizza
Pizza restaurant
Pizzas by the slice or pie with classic & creative toppings, salads & subs in a no-frills setting.
$ $$$
3.70 (648 reviews)
Capriccio image
10
Capriccio
Italian restaurant
Upscale restaurant with an ocean view in Resorts Casino, offering classic Italian cuisine.
4.40 (641 reviews)
Chelsea Pizza II image
11
Chelsea Pizza II
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Honestly the best chicken parmesan over pasta I've ever had! Discovered the place on a recommendation from a worker at the hotel I was at, and honestly, went back to Atlantic City a few days ago and couldn't leave without eating there! Staff is awesome as well!
$ $$$
4.00 (625 reviews)
Angeline by Michael Symon image
12
Angeline by Michael Symon
Restaurant
Elevated classic Italian fare & a vast wine list in sleek surrounds at the Borgata Hotel Casino.
$$$ $
3.70 (552 reviews)
Setaara image
13
Setaara
Restaurant
Trendy, colorful restaurant offering French & Afghan classics & desserts, plus a heated courtyard.
4.40 (492 reviews)
Girasole image
14
Girasole
Italian restaurant
High-end restaurant boasting Italian fare, including homemade pastas, plus a lounge & garden patio.
$$$ $
4.40 (401 reviews)
Linguini By The Sea image
15
Linguini By The Sea
Restaurant
Modern, glass-encased hotel restaurant offering Italian classics & wines, plus ocean views.
4.00 (385 reviews)
The Twenties Italian Bistro image
16
The Twenties Italian Bistro
Italian restaurant
Warm, venerable Italian restaurant offering steaks & seafood plus an original speakeasy bar.
4.30 (375 reviews)
Il Mulino New York - Atlantic City image
17
Il Mulino New York - Atlantic City
Italian restaurant
Elegantly appointed, well-known restaurant focusing on sizable plates of Italian favorites.
$$$ $
4.10 (345 reviews)
La Strada at the Shore image
18
La Strada at the Shore
Italian restaurant
😠 So we are here at about the 1 hour and 10 minute mark and we still do not have our appetizers. Two tables next to us now have their dinners… party of 6 came in next to us and they seems to make them a priority…. I will post updates as to when we actually start to get the food… I hope it’s worth the...
3.70 (285 reviews)
Molto Pizza image
19
Molto Pizza
Pizza restaurant
👍 This place was pretty good and affordable for the boardwalk. I ordered their lemonade for $6 and I have to say it wasn’t the best. However, the service was awesome! Everyone was very helpful, friendly, and honestly a bit funny. My friend ordered mushroom pizza and the noises she was making indicated...
3.60 (277 reviews)
Rhythm & Spirits image
20
Rhythm & Spirits
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Great experience. Food was great. The pork chop was by far one of the best we have had. Everyone was super friendly. I think every person working there took time to talk to us or say hello! So welcoming. I will definitely go back again!
4.40 (264 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )