Most reviewed Restaurants in Key West, United States

1. 4.50 Sloppy Joe's   (10753 reviews) Landmark bar with eats & live music
2. 4.40 Conch Republic Seafood Company   (8353 reviews) Caribbean-style menu in open-air space
3. 4.60 Blue Heaven   (7754 reviews) Floridian-Caribbean fusion-fare icon
4. 4.60 Hogfish Bar & Grill   (5667 reviews) Bustling seafood shack by the harbor
5. 4.80 The Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory   (5603 reviews) Tropical habitat for butterflies & birds
6. 4.50 Two Friends Patio Restaurant   (4933 reviews) Longtime open-air bistro with karaoke
7. 4.60 El Siboney Restaurant   (4618 reviews) Homestyle Cuban cuisine & sangria
8. 4.50 Hog's Breath Saloon   (4110 reviews) Bar & live music venue with dance floor
9. 4.60 Irish Kevin's   (4058 reviews) Festive pub with live music
10. 4.20 Margaritaville Restaurant - Key West   (4006 reviews) Island-inspired eats & live music
11. 4.50 Caroline's Cafe   (3765 reviews) Regional cooking in a historic old house
12. 4.40 Schooner Wharf Bar   (3685 reviews) Fish fare & live music by the seaport
13. 4.30 El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar   (3568 reviews) Festive hot spot for Cuban cooking
14. 4.40 Half Shell Raw Bar   (3503 reviews) Laid-back seafood joint on the water
15. 4.50 Banana Cafe   (3467 reviews) Mellow haunt for French crêpes & more
16. 4.50 Opal Key Resort & Marina   (3456 reviews) €560
17. 4.60 Green Parrot Bar   (3426 reviews) Landmark saloon with frequent live music
18. 4.30 Hard Rock Cafe   (3281 reviews) Music-themed chain with an American menu
19. 4.70 DJ's Clam Shack   (3184 reviews) Lively outdoor stand for lobster rolls
20. 4.70 Better Than Sex - A Dessert Restaurant   (3170 reviews) Sophisticated dessert-only venue
21. 3.50 The Stoned Crab   (3125 reviews) Waterfront tavern for seafood & spirits
22. 4.70 Cuban Coffee Queen   (3015 reviews) Funky take-out spot for Cuban fare
23. 4.40 Fogarty's   (2873 reviews) Choice for American fare & frozen drinks
24. 4.70 Paradise Restaurant   (2684 reviews) Latin American cooking & a tropical vibe
25. 4.20 Southernmost Beach Resort   (2562 reviews) €278
26. 3.00 McDonald's   (2533 reviews) Iconic fast-food burger & fries chain
27. 4.50 Pepe's Cafe   (2494 reviews) Fixture for breakfast & surf 'n' turf
28. 4.50 Rams Head Southernmost   (2483 reviews) Hip outdoor bar with casual fare & music
29. 4.50 Sunset Pier   (2468 reviews) Dockside seafood destination
30. 4.20 Pinchers   (2458 reviews) Laid-back seafood eatery
31. 4.50 Willie T's   (2363 reviews) Vibrant, mostly outdoor watering hole
32. 4.70 Harpoon Harry's   (2307 reviews) American diner with a playful vibe
33. 4.50 Hurricane Hole   (2285 reviews) Informal seafood fare & boat dock views
34. 4.10 Denny's   (2275 reviews) American diner chain running since 1953
35. 4.70 Santiago's Bodega | Key West   (2253 reviews) Global eats & sangria in cozy digs
36. 4.70 Garbo's Grill @ Hanks!   (2187 reviews) Food stand for eclectic tacos & burgers
37. 4.60 Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe   (2131 reviews) Breakfast
38. 4.70 Latitudes   (2100 reviews) Stylish restaurant with sea views
39. 4.60 Moondog Cafe   (1942 reviews) Cottage cafe for eating & drinking
40. 4.30 Dante's Key West Pool Bar & Restaurant   (1911 reviews) Seafood & drinks served poolside
41. 4.40 Amigos Tortilla Bar   (1907 reviews) Mexican bites & gluten-free brews
42. 4.30 Alonzo's Oyster Bar   (1906 reviews) Casual seafood joint with ocean views
43. 3.80 IHOP   (1847 reviews) Diner chain known for its breakfast
44. 4.50 Louie's Backyard   (1808 reviews) Venerable Caribbean-American restaurant
45. 4.50 Roostica   (1797 reviews) Rustic trattoria with Neapolitan pizza
46. 4.60 Ocean Key Resort & Spa   (1796 reviews) €518
47. 4.50 Bagatelle   (1794 reviews) Historic setting & seafood-focused menu
48. 4.40 Jack Flats   (1791 reviews) Relaxed surf 'n' turf grill & sports bar
49. 4.00 Outback Steakhouse   (1781 reviews) Lively Australian-themed chain
50. 4.50 Boat House Bar & Grill   (1653 reviews) Sailing-themed American spot on the dock
51. 4.60 Smokin' Tuna Saloon   (1645 reviews) Open-air bar with seafood & live music
52. 4.50 Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria   (1595 reviews) Airy Italian place with a garden patio
53. 4.70 Cuban Coffee Queen Downtown   (1575 reviews) Neighborhood cafe for Cuban eats
54. 4.30 Island Dogs Bar   (1522 reviews) Hangout for live bands & American eats
55. 4.40 Viva Argentinian Steakhouse   (1519 reviews) Lively bar & grill with a patio
56. 4.30 Old Town Mexican Cafe   (1517 reviews) Seafood-heavy eats in a tropical setting
57. 4.50 Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa   (1466 reviews) €545
58. 4.70 La Grignote   (1451 reviews) Artisanal French cafe, bakery & bistro
59. 4.70 Square Grouper Bar and Grill   (1449 reviews) Casual stop for seafood & cocktails
60. 4.40 Salute! On The Beach   (1430 reviews) Italian eats in a casual surfside cafe
61. 4.50 Lucy's Retired Surfers Bar & Restaurant   (1430 reviews) Coastal-style pub plates & patio seating
62. 4.40 A&B Lobster House   (1428 reviews) Seafood specialties & a harbor view
63. 4.50 Pier House Resort & Spa   (1402 reviews) €484
64. 4.60 The Cafe   (1392 reviews) Creative vegetarian eats amid local art
65. 4.60 Mr. Z's   (1323 reviews) Lively no-frills pizza & sandwich spot
66. 4.30 Duffy's Steak & Lobster House   (1318 reviews) Simple surf 'n' turf in a casual setting
67. 4.10 Mangoes Restaurant   (1310 reviews) Busy spot for seafood & people-watching
68. 4.60 Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant   (1268 reviews) Seafood sandwiches & fried fish
69. 4.40 Publix Super Market at Key Plaza Shopping Center   (1263 reviews) Supermarket chain for groceries & more
70. 4.30 Sandbar Sports Grill   (1224 reviews) Sports bar with live entertainment
71. 4.40 First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery   (1219 reviews) American eatery with a shaded courtyard
72. 3.80 Wendy's   (1213 reviews) Fast-food burger chain
73. 4.10 Turtle Kraals   (1185 reviews) Waterfront fish, drinks & turtle races
74. 4.40 Nine One Five   (1184 reviews) Inventive American fare in an old house
75. 4.20 The Waterfront Brewery   (1159 reviews) Spacious brewpub & restaurant
76. 4.60 Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden   (1144 reviews) Traditional & new pub fare in busy spot
77. 4.60 Duetto Pizza and Gelato   (1141 reviews) Pizza, sandwiches & gelato
78. 3.70 Taco Bell   (1109 reviews) Mexican-inspired fast-food chain
79. 4.40 B.O.'s Fish Wagon   (1105 reviews) Funky pit stop for seafood & sandwiches
80. 4.50 the breakfast club, too   (1069 reviews) Breakfast & lunch cafe with Bloody Marys
81. 4.40 New York Pasta Garden   (1061 reviews) Casual Italian fare & breakfast
82. 4.20 Ocean Grill & Bar   (1042 reviews) Classy seafood option with a patio
83. 4.40 Charlie Mac's   (1025 reviews) CLOSED
84. 4.50 Thirsty Mermaid   (1015 reviews) Casual seafood place with a raw bar
85. 4.60 Kim’s Kuban   (990 reviews) Compact joint for Cuban & Mexican grub
86. 4.50 La Crêperie French Café Key West   (988 reviews) Cozy cafe for French breakfast & lunch
87. 4.50 Sarabeth's Key West   (959 reviews) Upscale American spot for brunch & more
88. 4.30 Chico's Cantina   (949 reviews) Homey seafood-focused Mexican spot
89. 3.90 Southernmost Beach Cafe   (946 reviews) Surfside, open-air American dining spot
90. 3.60 Sonic Drive-In   (944 reviews) Fast-food burger chain with retro flair
91. 4.40 Five Guys   (942 reviews) Fast-food burger & fries chain
92. 4.70 The Lobster Shack Key West   (933 reviews) Classic seafood joint with beer & wine
93. 4.60 Tavern N' Town   (927 reviews) Big, sleek tapas spot with open kitchen
94. 4.50 Mangia Mangia   (909 reviews) Homestyle Italian fare & tropical flair
95. 4.70 "Off The Hook" Grill   (902 reviews) Snug bistro with seafood & American fare
96. 4.40 Fernandy's Cafe   (899 reviews) CLOSED
97. 4.50 Frita's Cuban Burgers   (895 reviews) Charming shop for street-style snacks
98. 4.60 El Siboney Restaurant ( Stock Island)   (891 reviews) Comfort food
99. 4.70 Clemente's Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria   (890 reviews) Pizza & comfort food in old-school digs
100. 4.50 Firefly Key West   (875 reviews) Modern Southern eats in a warm ambiance

Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps

What's a Most reviewed?

The list is sorted by the number of ratings. The higher position in the list - the more reviews the place has. in Restaurants category .

This page was last updated on Dec 12, 2022.

Request an update