1
The Gardens Hotel
Hotel
Landmark lodging with airy, elegant rooms, plus a courtyard pool, a bar & tropical gardens.
4.90 (561 reviews)
4
Orchid Key Inn
Hotel
Polished quarters, some with whirlpool tubs, in a hotel offering an outdoor pool, a hot tub & a bar.
4.80 (337 reviews)
5
The Capitana Key West
Hotel
Laid-back hotel opposite the Gulf of Mexico offering an outdoor pool, a poolside cafe/bar & a gym.
4.70 (583 reviews)
6
Ocean Key Resort & Spa
Resort hotel
Island-style hotel featuring rooms with whirlpool tubs, plus a spa, restaurant & poolside lounge.
4.60 (2K reviews)
7
Almond Tree Inn
Hotel
Cozy, contemporary quarters in a motel offering a heated outdoor pool, a hot tub & free breakfast.
4.80 (318 reviews)
8
H2O Suites Hotel
Hotel
Chic suites in a contemporary property with a rooftop pool & a landscaped courtyard.
4.80 (306 reviews)
9
La Te Da
Hotel
Low-key lodging for over-21s only offering airy rooms, a pool, a restaurant & on-site cabaret shows.
4.60 (1.4K reviews)
10
Santa Maria Suites Resort
Hotel
Sophisticated hotel with airy suites, some with garden views, plus 2 pools & a Japanese eatery.
4.70 (478 reviews)
11
Galleon Resort
Resort hotel
Modern hotel with a marina & ocean views, plus a private beach, a tiki bar and an observation deck.
4.60 (1K reviews)
12
Speakeasy Inn & Rum Bar
Hotel
Bright suites with kitchenettes in a 19th-century inn offering a cocktail bar & a wraparound porch.
4.80 (277 reviews)
14
Silver Palms Inn
Hotel
Colorful, island-themed rooms with balconies in a modern hotel with a saltwater pool & a sundeck.
4.60 (868 reviews)
15
Marquesa Hotel
Hotel
Classic rooms in a Victorian-era hotel with lush gardens, plus 2 pools, a restaurant & a bar.
4.80 (263 reviews)
16
Sunset Key Cottages
Resort hotel
Refined resort on a 27-acre island featuring a restaurant/bar, a spa & an outdoor pool.
4.60 (804 reviews)
17
Opal Key Resort & Marina
Resort hotel
Airy rooms & suites, some with ocean views, in a polished resort offering dining, a pool & a marina.
4.50 (3.8K reviews)
20
The Mansion On The Sea
Hotel
Historic Victorian inn & adjacent vacation home offering continental breakfast & a heated pool.
4.60 (505 reviews)